Notebookcheck Logo

ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4860 vs NVIDIA Quadro K5100M

ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4860

► remove from comparison

The Mobility HD 4860 is based off of the 40nm RV740 core with less shader cores than the Mobility HD 4850 and only a 128 bit memory bus. Because of the high core clock and GDDR5 memory, the card should still be able to perform comparatively fast.

An initial review of the desktop HD 4750 with similar specifications than the Mobility HD 4860 (but at higher clock rates) shows a score of 6000 points in the GPU test of 3DMark Vantage. According to our benchmarks, this score puts the AMD card above the GeForce 280M.

AMD has also published a benchmark comparison between the HD 4850 and HD 4860 mobile graphics cards and showed that the 4860 was able to perform a few percentage points better in 3DMark06 under 1920x1200 pixel resolution.

 

At Cebit 2009, Asus showed us a 15" laptop with a Mobility Radeon HD 4860 for a hopeful launch in Q2 2009. Our press contact stated that the mobile HD 4860 may perform a bit worse than the mobile HD 4850. In the presented pre-production sample, there was an unspecified "Mobility Radeon 4500 Series" graphics card installed that scored only a bit above 2000 points in 3DMark06.

The features of the HD 4860 should be comparable to the HD 4850 with regards to Avivo HD video functionality, Powerplay and the integrated sound controller for HDMI output.

NVIDIA Quadro K5100M

► remove from comparison NVIDIA Quadro K5100M

The NVIDIA Quadro K5100M is a high-end, DirectX 11 and OpenGL 4.3 compatible graphics card for mobile workstations. It is a Kepler-based GPU built on the GK104 chip with all 1536 shader cores activated and is manufactured in 28nm at TSMC. The Quadro K5100M is built for the Intel Shark Bay generation (Haswell) and as a successor to the Quadro K5000M (Chief River platform). As a new feature, PCIe 3.0 is supported for the first time. The K5100M usually comes with 8 GB GDDR5 VRAM clocked at 900 MHz (3600 MHz effective, 115.2 GB/s). 

The Quadro series offers certified drivers that are optimized for stability and performance in professional applications like CAD or DCC. OpenGL performance, for example, should be significantly better compared to GeForce graphics cards of similar specifications.

Architecture

The Kepler architecture is the successor to the Fermi architecture that first appeared in laptops with the GeForce 400M series. The GK104 Kepler core offers eight shader blocks, called SMX, that are clocked at the same speed as the central core. In the K5100M, all 8 blocks are active leading to the 1536 CUDA cores. Although more shader cores are available in the Kepler architecture as compared to the Fermi design, the Kepler shaders are still expected to be up to twice as power efficient. However, due to the missing hot clock of the shader domain, two shaders of a Kepler chip offer similar performance to just one shader of a Fermi chip (as the latter is clocked twice as fast).

Performance

The 3D gaming performance of the K5100M is clearly above the old Quadro K5000M, but about 10 percent below the slightly higher clocked GTX 780M. Nevertheless, most demanding games of 2013 will run fluently with maxed out details and very high resolutions.

Features

The improved feature set now includes support for up to 4 active displays. Furthermore, high resolution monitors of up to 3840 x 2160 pixels can now be connected using DisplayPort 1.2 or HDMI 1.4a if available. HD-Audio codecs, such as Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD, can be transmitted via bitstream mode through the HDMI port. However, as most laptops will feature Optimus, the integrated GPU will likely have direct control over the display ports and may limit the feature set available by the Nvidia Kepler cards.

Using CUDA or OpenCL 1.2, the cores of the Quadro K5100M can be used for general calculations.

The 5th generation PureVideo HD video processor (VP5) is also integrated in the GK104 core and offers hardware decoding of HD videos. Common codecs such as MPEG-1/2, MPEG-4 ASP, H.264 and VC1/WMV9 are fully supported up to 4K resolutions while VC1 and MPEG-4 are supported up to 1080p. Two streams can be decoded in parallel for features such as Picture-in-Picture. Another novelty is the inclusion of a dedicated video encoding engine similar to Intel QuickSync that can be accessed by the NVENC API.

Power Consumption

The power consumption of the Quadro K5100M is rated at a TGP of 100 W including the board and memory components. Therefore, the card is suited for large notebooks with 17-inch displays or greater.

ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4860NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
Quadro K Series
Mobility Radeon HD 4860 640 @ 0.65 GHz128 Bit @ 1000 MHz
Mobility Radeon HD 4850 compare 800 @ 0.5 GHz256 Bit @ 850 MHz
Mobility Radeon HD 4830 compare 640 @ 0.55 GHz128 Bit @ 700 MHz
Quadro K5100M 1536 @ 0.77 GHz256 Bit @ 3600 MHz
Quadro K5000M compare 1344 @ 0.71 GHz256 Bit @ 3000 MHz
Quadro K4100M compare 1152 @ 0.71 GHz256 Bit @ 3200 MHz
Quadro K4000M compare 960 @ 0.6 GHz256 Bit @ 2800 MHz
Quadro K3100M compare 768 @ 0.71 GHz256 Bit @ 3200 MHz
Quadro K3000M compare 576 @ 0.65 GHz256 Bit @ 2800 MHz
Quadro K2100M compare 576 @ 0.67 GHz128 Bit @ 3000 MHz
Quadro K1100M compare 384 @ 0.71 GHz128 Bit @ 2800 MHz
Quadro K620M compare 384 @ 1.03 - 1.12 GHz64 Bit @ 2000 MHz
Quadro K2000M compare 384 @ 0.75 GHz128 Bit @ 1800 MHz
Quadro K1000M compare 192 @ 0.85 GHz128 Bit @ 1800 MHz
Quadro K610M compare 192 @ 0.95 GHz64 Bit @ 2600 MHz
Quadro K510M compare 192 @ 0.85 GHz64 Bit @ 2400 MHz
Quadro K500M compare 192 @ 0.85 GHz64 Bit @ 1800 MHz
CodenameM97-XTN15E-Q5-A2
ArchitectureTerascale 1Kepler
Pipelines640 - unified1536 - unified
Core Speed650 MHz771 MHz
Memory Speed1000 MHz3600 MHz
Memory Bus Width128 Bit256 Bit
Memory TypeGDDR5GDDR5
Shared Memorynono
APIDirectX 10.1, Shader 4.1DirectX 11, Shader 5.0, OpenGL 4.3
Transistors826 Million3.5 Billion
technology40 nm28 nm
FeaturesPowerplay, CrossFireX support, Optimus, PhysX, Verde Drivers, CUDA, OpenCL 1.2, 3D Vision, 3DTV Play
Notebook Sizelargelarge
Date of Announcement03.03.2009 23.07.2013
Information832 GFlops Computing Power
Link to Manufacturer Pageati.amd.comwww.nvidia.com
Max. Amount of Memory8 GB
Power Consumption100 Watt

Benchmarks

Performance Rating - 3DMark 11 + Fire Strike + Time Spy - Quadro K5100M
2.2 pt (7%)
3DMark - 3DMark Ice Storm Unlimited Graphics
2197 Points (0%)
3DMark - 3DMark Ice Storm Extreme Graphics
171011 Points (22%)
3DMark - 3DMark Cloud Gate Score
min: 17381     avg: 18985     median: 17583 (19%)     max: 21992 Points
3DMark - 3DMark Cloud Gate Graphics
min: 28522     avg: 30438     median: 31015 (8%)     max: 31777 Points
3DMark - 3DMark Fire Strike Standard Score
min: 4392     avg: 4444     median: 4467 (8%)     max: 4473 Points
3DMark - 3DMark Fire Strike Standard Graphics
min: 4759     avg: 4818     median: 4793 (5%)     max: 4902 Points
3DMark - 3DMark Ice Storm Graphics
min: 137763     avg: 169246     median: 154518 (19%)     max: 215458 Points
3DMark 11 - 3DM11 Performance Score
min: 6839     avg: 7041     median: 7058 (10%)     max: 7210 Points
3DMark 11 - 3DM11 Performance GPU
min: 6655     avg: 6894     median: 6880 (6%)     max: 7148 Points
3DMark Vantage
3DM Vant. Perf. total + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
3DMark Vantage - 3DM Vant. Perf. total
24795 Points (7%)
3DM Vant. Perf. GPU no PhysX + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
3DMark Vantage - 3DM Vant. Perf. GPU no PhysX
24457 Points (14%)
3DMark 06 3DMark 06 - Standard 1280x1024 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
3DMark 06
min: 24627     avg: 24910     median: 24910 (33%)     max: 25193 Points
SPECviewperf 11
specvp11 snx-01 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 11 - specvp11 snx-01
47.7 fps (28%)
specvp11 tcvis-02 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 11 - specvp11 tcvis-02
min: 48.74     avg: 49.5     median: 49.5 (28%)     max: 50.3 fps
specvp11 sw-02 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 11 - specvp11 sw-02
min: 49.03     avg: 53.6     median: 53.6 (41%)     max: 58.1 fps
specvp11 proe-05 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 11 - specvp11 proe-05
min: 11.01     avg: 13.4     median: 13.4 (16%)     max: 15.77 fps
specvp11 maya-03 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 11 - specvp11 maya-03
min: 57.6     avg: 70.7     median: 70.7 (53%)     max: 83.7 fps
specvp11 lightwave-01 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 11 - specvp11 lightwave-01
min: 52     avg: 59.4     median: 59.4 (64%)     max: 66.7 fps
specvp11 ensight-04 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 11 - specvp11 ensight-04
min: 58.6     avg: 69.6     median: 69.6 (33%)     max: 80.5 fps
specvp11 catia-03 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 11 - specvp11 catia-03
min: 47.91     avg: 55.9     median: 55.9 (29%)     max: 63.9 fps
SPECviewperf 12
specvp12 sw-03 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 12 - specvp12 sw-03
min: 34.81     avg: 60.9     median: 60.9 (15%)     max: 87 fps
specvp12 snx-02 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 12 - specvp12 snx-02
min: 56.9     avg: 71.1     median: 71.1 (11%)     max: 85.3 fps
specvp12 showcase-01 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 12 - specvp12 showcase-01
min: 27     avg: 27.4     median: 27.4 (6%)     max: 27.73 fps
specvp12 mediacal-01 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 12 - specvp12 mediacal-01
min: 13.26     avg: 18     median: 18 (5%)     max: 22.66 fps
specvp12 maya-04 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 12 - specvp12 maya-04
min: 40.91     avg: 44.4     median: 44.4 (12%)     max: 47.94 fps
specvp12 energy-01 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 12 - specvp12 energy-01
min: 1.76     avg: 2.2     median: 2.2 (2%)     max: 2.58 fps
specvp12 creo-01 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 12 - specvp12 creo-01
min: 37.95     avg: 43.1     median: 43.1 (17%)     max: 48.29 fps
specvp12 catia-04 + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
SPECviewperf 12 - specvp12 catia-04
min: 55.3     avg: 58.8     median: 58.8 (10%)     max: 62.3 fps
Cinebench R10 Cinebench R10 Shading (32bit) + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
Cinebench R10 - Cinebench R10 Shading (32bit)
min: 5443     avg: 6244     median: 6539 (5%)     max: 6751 Points
Cinebench R11.5 Cinebench R11.5 OpenGL 64 Bit + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
Cinebench R11.5 - Cinebench R11.5 OpenGL 64 Bit
min: 66.2     avg: 94.3     median: 102.1 (35%)     max: 114.5 fps
Cinebench R15
Cinebench R15 OpenGL 64 Bit + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
Cinebench R15 - Cinebench R15 OpenGL 64 Bit
min: 93.7     avg: 119.3     median: 119.3 (7%)     max: 144.8 fps
Cinebench R15 OpenGL Ref. Match 64 Bit + NVIDIA Quadro K5100M
Cinebench R15 - Cinebench R15 OpenGL Ref. Match 64 Bit
99.6 % (100%)
LuxMark v2.0 64Bit - LuxMark v2.0 Room GPU
417 Samples/s (2%)
LuxMark v2.0 64Bit - LuxMark v2.0 Sala GPU
774 Samples/s (1%)

Average Benchmarks NVIDIA Quadro K5100M → 0% n=

- Range of benchmark values for this graphics card
- Average benchmark values for this graphics card
* Smaller numbers mean a higher performance
1 This benchmark is not used for the average calculation

Game Benchmarks

The following benchmarks stem from our benchmarks of review laptops. The performance depends on the used graphics memory, clock rate, processor, system settings, drivers, and operating systems. So the results don't have to be representative for all laptops with this GPU. For detailed information on the benchmark results, click on the fps number.

low 1280x720
Quadro K5100M:
65  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
54  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
33  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
23  fps
4K 3840x2160
Quadro K5100M:
11  fps
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
70.8  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
44  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
25  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
13.5  fps
4K 3840x2160
Quadro K5100M:
9.6  fps
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
401.9  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
147.4  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
81.5  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
39  fps
4K 3840x2160
Quadro K5100M:
32.3  fps
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
184.5  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
145.5  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
58.9  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
37.7  fps
Evolve

Evolve

2015
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
103.2  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
79.1  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
43.4  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
38.1  fps
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
143.4  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
103.5  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
37.5  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
25.9  fps
Far Cry 4

Far Cry 4

2014
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
112.4  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
89.4  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
40.4  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
31  fps
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
58.1  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
42.6  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
28.8  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
16.2  fps
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
112.8  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
75.9  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
46.9  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
28.3  fps
F1 2014

F1 2014

2014
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
120  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
119  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
119  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
108  fps
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
80.8  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
64.7  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
33.7  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
31.7  fps
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
205.1  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
143.4  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
79.8  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
54.8  fps
low 1280x720
Quadro K5100M:
125.9  fps
med. 1344x756
Quadro K5100M:
84.2  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
45.7  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
35.8  fps
Fifa 15

Fifa 15

2014
low 1280x720
Quadro K5100M:
299.7  fps
high 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
213.2  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
153  fps
4K 3840x2160
Quadro K5100M:
77.4  fps
Sims 4

Sims 4

2014
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
180  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
132.6  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
96.3  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
77.9  fps
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
319.7  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
176.3  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
119.4  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
58.8  fps
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
111.3  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
84.9  fps
high 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
35.3  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
25.8  fps
Thief

Thief

2014
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
57.4  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
50.7  fps
high 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
49.6  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
45.4  fps
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
169.6  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
122.6  fps
high 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
89.5  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
36.5  fps
4K 3840x2160
Quadro K5100M:
19.8  fps
F1 2013

F1 2013

2013
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
118  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
119  fps
high 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
119  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
107  fps
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
61.8  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
58 59 ~ 59 fps
high 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
39.8 58 ~ 49 fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
19.5 20 ~ 20 fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
91  fps
high 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
60  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
33  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
157  fps
high 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
132  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
49  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
122  fps
high 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
106  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
65  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
203  fps
high 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
128  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
58  fps
Crysis 3

Crysis 3

2013
low 1024x768
Quadro K5100M:
136.1  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
92.1  fps
high 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
63.4  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
25.8  fps
high 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
58  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
39  fps
med. 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
123  fps
high 1366x768
Quadro K5100M:
91  fps
ultra 1920x1080
Quadro K5100M:
31  fps
NVIDIA Quadro K5100Mlowmed.highultraQHD4K
Batman: Arkham Knight6554332311
The Witcher 370.8442513.59.6
Dirt Rally401.9147.481.53932.3
Battlefield Hardline184.5145.558.937.7
Evolve103.279.143.438.1
Dragon Age: Inquisition143.4103.537.525.9
Far Cry 4112.489.440.431
Assassin's Creed Unity58.142.628.816.2
Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare112.875.946.928.3
F1 2014120119119108
Ryse: Son of Rome80.864.733.731.7
Alien: Isolation205.1143.479.854.8
Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor125.984.245.735.8
Fifa 15299.7213.215377.4
Sims 4180132.696.377.9
GRID: Autosport319.7176.3119.458.8
Watch Dogs111.384.935.325.8
Thief57.450.749.645.4
Battlefield 4169.6122.689.536.519.8
F1 2013118119119107
Company of Heroes 261.8594920
Metro: Last Light916033
BioShock Infinite15713249
StarCraft II: Heart of the Swarm12210665
Tomb Raider20312858
Crysis 3136.192.163.425.8
Guild Wars 25839
Sleeping Dogs1239131
< 30 fps
< 60 fps
< 120 fps
≥ 120 fps

2
9
11

5
11
10
2
12
11
3
8
15
4
1



3
1
1

For more games that might be playable and a list of all games and graphics cards visit our Gaming List

Add one or more devices and compare

In the following list you can select (and also search for) devices that should be added to the comparison. You can select more than one device.

restrict list:

show all (including archived), 2024, 2023
v1.27
log 16. 07:16:50

#0 checking url part for id 1117 +0s ... 0s

#1 checking url part for id 4829 +0s ... 0s

#2 not redirecting to Ajax server +0s ... 0s

#3 did not recreate cache, as it is less than 5 days old! Created at Sun, 16 Jun 2024 05:38:48 +0200 +0.001s ... 0.001s

#4 composed specs +0.114s ... 0.115s

#5 did output specs +0s ... 0.115s

#6 start showIntegratedCPUs +0s ... 0.115s

#7 getting avg benchmarks for device 1117 +0.031s ... 0.146s

#8 got single benchmarks 1117 +0s ... 0.147s

#9 getting avg benchmarks for device 4829 +0.023s ... 0.17s

#10 got single benchmarks 4829 +0.016s ... 0.186s

#11 got avg benchmarks for devices +0s ... 0.186s

#12 min, max, avg, median took s +0.224s ... 0.41s

#13 before gaming benchmark output +0s ... 0.41s

#14 Got 112 rows for game benchmarks. +0.015s ... 0.425s

#15 composed SQL query for gamebenchmarks +0s ... 0.425s

#16 got data and put it in $dataArray +0.022s ... 0.447s

#17 benchmarks composed for output. +0.069s ... 0.516s

#18 calculated avg scores. +0s ... 0.516s

#19 return log +0.061s ... 0.577s

Please share our article, every link counts!
> Expert Reviews and News on Laptops, Smartphones and Tech Innovations > Benchmarks / Tech > Graphics Card Comparison - Head 2 Head
Redaktion, 2017-09- 8 (Update: 2023-07- 1)