Notebookcheck Logo

iFixit: Apple MacBook Pro stage light issue turns "a $6 problem into a $600 disaster"

Several users have complained of MacBook Pros exhibiting the 'stage light' effect. (Source: Alex P. on Change.org)
Several users have complained of MacBook Pros exhibiting the 'stage light' effect. (Source: Alex P. on Change.org)
Several users have complained of a 'stage light' anomaly in their MacBook Pro displays. iFixit wrote in a blog post that it has identified the cause of the issue and attributes it to the manner in which the display cables connect to the display controller beneath the Touch Bar. This design causes the cables to tear overtime giving the uneven backlighting effect when the display is opened beyond a certain angle. More worrisome, however, is the fact that getting it repaired can prove to be a costly affair.
Apple Fail MacBook

Apple's latest MacBook Pros are not new to incongruous design and technical choices and the latest complaint from many MacBook Pro users is being described as 'flexgate'. MacBook Pros suffering from flexgate are prone to several problems with the display, prominent of them being a 'stage light' issue that is seen at the bottom of the screen that often leads to a total shutdown of the display's backlight after opening the display at a certain angle.

iFixit took a look at the issue and attributed it to the fatiguing of the thin flexible ribbon cables that connect the display to the display controller board beneath the Touch Bar. Apparently, the manner in which the cables wrap around the controller board can subject them to stress everytime the laptop's lid is opened and closed resulting in their wear and tear including that of the backlight cable. This results in the 'stage light' effect and eventually the backlight stops working when the display is opened at more than a 40-degree angle.

Apple's quest for thinness has made them to opt for these fragile flexible cables instead of the traditional wire cables that were routed through the hinge in MacBook Pros prior to 2016. Compounding the problem is that these thin flex cables are part of the display assembly and cannot be repaired independent of a total display replacement that will burn a US$600 hole in the pocket for what is effectively a US$6 problem. 

A user, Alex, has started a petition on his site flexgate.me requesting Apple to announce an extended warranty program to address this issue. According to the site, the all MacBook Pros with Touch Bar from 2016 onwards are affected. These include —

Users who have experienced this issue after the warranty period say that they had to cough up the dough to get the display replaced at the local Genius Bar. The issue seems to be widespread, but Apple is yet to offer free service for what is clearly a QC issue on its part.

Alex's petition has currently gathered around 5,000 signatures so far. If you're one of those affected, we suggest you add your name to it as well. Here's hoping Apple yields to those who have spent quite a fortune on their MacBook Pro purchases.

Are you affected by backlight issues on your MacBook Pro? Let us know in the comments below.

The fragile flexible display cables around the display controller in the new MacBook Pros with Touch Bar can wear out overtime as they are pulled taut. (Source: iFixit)
The fragile flexible display cables around the display controller in the new MacBook Pros with Touch Bar can wear out overtime as they are pulled taut. (Source: iFixit)

Source(s)

Related Articles

iPhone 12 Pro Max teardown reveals generous image sensor but rather small battery (Source: iFixit)
iFixit tears down the iPhone 12 Pro Max to reveal a 47% larger image sensor than the one used for the iPhone 12 11/23/2020
MacBook Pro with a broken flex cable showing
Apple may face another class-action lawsuit for display cable flaw in 2016 and 2017 MacBook Pros 08/20/2020
The Lenovo Legion Y50-70 has numerous reports of failed hinge failure across the Lenovo product forums. (Source: Maglip on Lenovo Product Forums)
Fragile hardware can turn a great deal into a future expense 12/23/2019
iFixit's Mac Pro teardown: (Image source: iFixit)
"A masterclass in repairability": iFixit tears down the 2019 Mac Pro 12/23/2019
The Pixel 4 XL's display has now been confirmed to be supplied by Samsung Display. (Source: iFixit)
iFixit's Pixel 4 XL review shows the flagship's poor repairability, reveals important hardware details 10/24/2019
Apple MBP 15 2019 i7 disappoints in review – is Apple using selected test samples?
Apple MBP 15 2019 i7 disappoints in review – is Apple using selected test samples? 06/12/2019
The 15-inch MacBook Pro now comes with the option of an 8-core Intel Core i9 processor. (Source: Apple)
Apple launches refreshed MacBook Pro models with 9th gen Intel silicon and a keyboard 'tweak' 05/22/2019
Image via Apple.com
UltraFine to Ultra-rare: Apple seemingly removes LG UltraFine 5K display from its store 05/09/2019
Will there be a new Core i7 and Core i5 MacBook Air?
Intel confirms the existence of the Core i7 processor in last year's mysterious MacBook Air-like device 03/11/2019
Apple SVP of Retail will be leaving the company in April in a shock departure. (Source: Apple)
Apple retail chief Angela Ahrendts exits the company 02/06/2019
The bug was introduced with the 12.1 version of iOS in November 2018. (Source: Apple)
Apple gets sued over FaceTime critical flaw 01/30/2019
Tim Cook introduces Group Face Time. (Source: Ars Technica)
Group FaceGate: New iOS bug grants access to iPhone mic audio without its owner's knowledge 01/29/2019
The part of the iOS 12.2 code that may refer to a new iPod Touch. (Source: Twitter)
iOS 12.2 code hints at possible new iPads and iPod Touch 01/26/2019
Apple releases iPhone XS short movie The Bucket
Apple releases iPhone XS short movie The Bucket 01/25/2019
Apple MacBook Pro 15 – Core i9 slower than Core i7!
Apple MacBook Pro 15 – Core i9 slower than Core i7! 01/22/2019
Image source: Apple and AMD (w/ edits)
Vega comes to the MacBook Pro: new models with Vega Pro 16 and Vega Pro 20 GPUs now available 11/14/2018
The T2 chip found in new MacBooks. (Source: macsales.com)
Can you fix your own 2018 MacBook? An internal Apple report says no, but iFixit says yes 10/06/2018
BridgeOS in the Apple T2 chip is causing some instances of kernel panics in the iMac Pro and MacBook Pro. (Source: Digital Trends)
Apple T2 chip causing kernel panics in few 2018 MacBook Pros and iMac Pros 07/27/2018
A supplemental update to address throttling issues is now available. (Source: Apple)
Apple issues software fix to address thermal throttling in new MacBook Pro 07/25/2018
Teardown of the 2018 MacBook Pro keyboard revealed a membrane underneath. (Source: iFixit)
Apple service documents confirm presence of a membrane in the 2018 MacBook Pro keyboards 07/19/2018
The new protective membrane added to the 3rd-gen keyboard mechanism. (Source: iFixit)
iFixit: Apple may have sneakily fixed the MacBook Pro keyboard after all 07/14/2018
iFixit has cut the price of its iPhone DIY battery replacement kits. (Source: iFixit)
iFixit drops iPhone battery price to $29, matches Apple 12/31/2017
Read all 1 comments / answer
static version load dynamic
Loading Comments
Comment on this article
Please share our article, every link counts!
> Expert Reviews and News on Laptops, Smartphones and Tech Innovations > News > News Archive > Newsarchive 2019 01 > iFixit: Apple MacBook Pro stage light issue turns "a $6 problem into a $600 disaster"
Vaidyanathan Subramaniam, 2019-01-23 (Update: 2019-01-23)