Review Lenovo ThinkPad T510 Notebook (Optimus)

Martina Osztovits (translated by Daniel Rechitsky ), 12/21/2010

Optimus Update. To increase its battery life, the Lenovo Thinkpad T510 is now equipped with Optimus GPU-switching technology from Nvidia. The details on how this new feature affects the system as a whole and whether it's worth getting the upgrade, you'll find out in the following extensive review.

The Thinkpad T510 is in essense the Arrandale Upgrade of the T500.  The model we originally reviewed was fitted with an Intel Core i7 620M CPU, dedicated NVS 3100M GPU and unused on-board Intel GMA HD graphics card.  The hardware of the model in review here remains just about the same: Core i7 620M CPU, dedicated Nvidia Quadro NVS 3100M graphics card, four GB RAM and speedy 7200 RPM hard drive with 500 GP storage capacity.

The full HD screen is, however, new.  And since the notebook is otherwise structurally identical to the previously reviewed T510 model, we'll jump right to the display section.

Display

Wie wir testen - Display

Our test model was equipped with a full-HD screen, that is, with 1920x1080 pixel resolution, resulting in a movie-friendly 16:9 aspect ratio.  The screen (LEN40B2) measures 15.6" diagonally and has a non-reflective, matte surface typical of business notebooks.  The previously reviewed Thinkpad W510 with the same monitor ID exhibited an excellent color space thanks to its LED RGB screen among other outstanding attributes.  You can find out what screens are available for this notebook in our earlier review of the T510.

After establishing the screen's ICC profile, it becomes apparent that the notebook displays a very good color space.  sRGB and AdobeRGB are covered relatively well.  Its color space rating puts it just behind the discontinued Dell Studio XPS 16 with an RGB LED display and on par with the current XPS 15.

T510 vs sRGB (transparent)
T510 vs sRGB (transparent)
T510 vs AdobeRGB (transparent)
T510 vs AdobeRGB (transparent)
T510 vs MBP 17 (transparent)
T510 vs MacBook Pro 17 (transparent)
T510 vs Dell XPS 15 (transparent)
T510 vs Dell XPS 15 (transparent)
T510 vs Dell Studio XPS 16 (transparent)
T510 vs Dell Studio XPS 16 (transparent)

The other display-related measurements are quite good.  The values for our in-review model match those of the previously tested Thinkpad W510.  At a maximum of 265 cd/m² and an average screen brightness of 237.3 cd/m², the screen is quite bright and exhibits fairly good brightness distribution, as a matter of fact.  Thanks to the low black level of 0.47 cd/m², the contrast ratio comes to an excellent 564:1.

Corroborating the numbers, colors appear sharp and crisp.  Black areas appear jet black.  To top it all off, print looks nice and sharp.

228
cd/m²
224
cd/m²
226
cd/m²
241
cd/m²
265
cd/m²
233
cd/m²
242
cd/m²
242
cd/m²
234
cd/m²
Distribution of brightness
Information
Gossen Mavo-Monitor
Maximum: 265 cd/m²
Average: 237.2 cd/m²
Brightness Distribution: 85 %
Black: 0.47 cd/m²
Contrast: 564:1
Outdoor Use
Outdoor Use

The T510 displays screen content excellently outdoors thanks to its well lit, matte screen.  Using the notebook outdoors in the shade brings up no problems at all, although using it in direct sunlight might make you wish the screen were a bit brighter.  In this light, the T510 trumps the Dell XPS 15 and other consumer notebooks with reflective, glare-prone screens.

In terms of the range of viewing angles, the T510's screen contents can still be seen clearly at sharp angles to the left and right of the screen.  Vertically, the range is a good deal smaller but sufficient as is typical for many notebooks.

Viewing Angles Lenovo ThinkPad T510 - 4384-GEG
Viewing Angles Lenovo ThinkPad T510 - 4384-GEG

Performance

Compared to the hardware of the previously reviewed T510-4349-4JG, the Optimus graphics card switching component was added for the sake of saving energy.  Other than that, both models are based on the mobile Intel QM57 Express Chipset and use a Core i7 620M CPU—a dual-core processor of the Arrandale processor family.  With the Turbo Boost function, each core can be overclocked depending on CPU load.  Hyperthreading allows for the simultaneous processing of up to four threads.

In contrast to the previously reviewed model, the model in review here comes with 4 GB DDR3 RAM—PC3-10700 (667 MHz) instead of the PC3-8500F (533 MHz).  This memory comes in the form of a single RAM chip easily accessible through a maintenance opening.  Comparably to the 32-bit version of the OS, the memory is used efficiently in the 64-bit version of Windows 7 Professional.  And nothing stands in your way if you want to upgrade your RAM.  Moreover, the CPU is equipped with a controller that can address up to 8 GB of memory.

Systeminfo CPUZ CPU
Systeminfo CPUZ Cache
Systeminfo CPUZ Mainboard
Systeminfo CPUZ RAM
Systeminfo CPUZ RAM SPD
Systeminfo GPUZ
Systeminfo GPUZ
DPCLatency
System Properties Lenovo ThinkPad T510 - 4384-GEG

The pretty colors appearing on the screen are processed by the Quadro NVS 3100M graphics card from Nvidia, the exact same one used in the previously reviewed T510-4349-4JG model.  This business GPU supports DirectX 10.1 and is based on the GT218 core (GeForce 210M, 310M) and therefore offers entry-level performance.  The drivers are configured to business applications and therefore offer best compatibility and stability.  With Purevideo HD (VP4), the graphics card supports the decoding of HD material (H.264, VC1, MPEG2, MPEG4 ASP).  Through CUDA and DirectX Compute, the graphics card can also aid the CPU in various computations.  

For energy-saving purposes, the dedicated NVS 3100M graphics card can now be automatically shut off, that is, switched to the on-board GMA HD video card.  Considering that we are interested in the best possible performance in this section, all performance tests were done with the NVS 3100M on.

3.9
Windows 7 Experience Index
Processor
Calculations per second
6.9
Memory (RAM)
Memory operations per second
5.9
Graphics
Desktop performance for Windows Aero
3.9
Gaming graphics
3D business and gaming graphics
5.7
Primary hard disk
Disk data transfer rate
5.9
Cinebench R10 Rendering Single 32Bit
3569
Cinebench R10 Rendering Multiple CPUs 32Bit
7742
Cinebench R10 Shading 32Bit
4162
Cinebench R10 Rendering Single CPUs 64Bit
3555 Points
Cinebench R10 Rendering Multiple CPUs 64Bit
7510 Points
Cinebench R10 Shading 64Bit
4563 Points
Cinebench R11.5 OpenGL 64Bit
8.56 fps
Cinebench R11.5 CPU Multi 64Bit
2.45 Points
Help
PC Mark
PCMark Vantage6778 points
Help

Turning to the application performance tests, the PCMarkVantage benchmark awarded our test model an overall score of 6778 points.  Our previously reviewed model received 5576 points, making the Optimus version around 20% better in this regard.

Taking a look at the individual scores that made up the total, we see a better Memory Score (3718 vs. 3621 Punkte), a higher Hard Disk Score (4189 vs. 3719 Punkte) and a much better Productivity Score (6522 vs. 3827) for the Optimus model.  The recently reviewed Dell XPS 15 with a score of 6602 points is just about on par with the Optimus model.  Moreover, an additional improvement to the overall score can be achieved by using an SSD (Solid State Drive).

3D Mark
3DMark 039356 points
3DMark 056461 points
3DMark 06
 1280x1024
3285 points
3DMark Vantage1121 points
Help
Seagate Momentus 7200.4 ST9500420AS
Transfer Rate Minimum: 48.5 MB/s
Transfer Rate Maximum: 104.9 MB/s
Transfer Rate Average: 81.4 MB/s
Access Time: 16 ms
Burst Rate: 85.3 MB/s
HDTune
HDTune
CrystalDiskMark
CrystalDiskMark

For all your data storage needs, the conventional Seagate ST9500420AS hard drive is at your disposal.  It runs at 7200 RPM and has a storage capacity of 500 GB.  Another Seagate hard drive, the ST9320423AS, shows slower transfer rates in the HDTune Benchmark as well as longer access times.  This explains the higher rating for the HDD in our test model in the PCMarkVantage benchmark.

Graphics Card Performance

Both T510 models perform relatively the same in the 3DMark tests.  The CinebenchR10 Shading Test, interestingly enough, awards the Optimus model +24% over the other version.  Of course, the Lenovo Thinkpad T510 doesn't have a chance against the previously mentioned Dell XPS 15—which is furnished with a mid-grade consumer graphics card (Nvidia GeForce GT 435M). Because of the relatively similar results of the 3DMark test and because the T510 is really meant for business use, we didn't run any more GPU or gaming tests.  For further information on the GPU and gaming, please refer to the review of the T510-4349-4JG model and our Gaming List.

Something worth mentioning: The Optimus driver installed in notebook (8.17.12.5738) is not the up-to-date version.  An update can make certain applications run better.  You can find the current version on the Nvidia website.

Emissions

System Noise

The in-review Optimus-model of the T510 took us by surprise in running somewhat louder.  No matter the level of stress on the hardware, the system noise remained more noticeable than it did with the previously reviewed T510 model that used only its dedicated graphics card.  This is astonishing because the power consumption under light use, that is, using the on-board Intel GMA HD graphics card should actually be lower.  A conceivable cause of this completely chaotic, confusing conundrum could be connected to the card's not quite current driver.  Updating the graphics card driver to the current version (260.99) does actually bring down the noise level noticeably in idle mode and under light office use even though the notebook remains clearly audible.

Noise Level

Idle 35.1 / 35.1 / 36 dB(A)
HDD 35.7 dB(A)
DVD 37.4 / dB(A)
Load 36 / 39.3 dB(A)
 
    30 dB
silent
40 dB
audible
50 dB
loud
 
min: , med: , max:    Voltcraft sl-300 Plus (15 cm distance)
Stress Test

Temperature

The case temperature remains somewhat lower for the Optimus model of the T510 in idle mode as well as the stress test than for the non-Optimus model.  This might be directly attributable to the cooling fan rather than being a benefit of the Optimus graphics card switching component.  Even during the several-hour-long stress test (during which the CPU and GPU are both at 100% load) the case temperature stays within reasonable bounds.  What's more, running 3DMark06 directly after the stress tests yields only slightly different results than the run-through done before the stress test. 

Max. Load
 36.2 °C28.4 °C24.8 °C 
 32.6 °C29.4 °C25.9 °C 
 24.9 °C24.8 °C23.3 °C 
Maximum: 36.2 °C
Average: 27.8 °C
37.9 °C31.8 °C24.3 °C
36.3 °C32.1 °C25.6 °C
32.6 °C27.9 °C26.9 °C
Maximum: 37.9 °C
Average: 30.6 °C
Power Supply (max.)  57.1 °C | Room Temperature 20.5 °C | Raytek Raynger ST

Battery Life

Readers Test
Readers Test
Classic Test
Classic Test
Battery Charging
Battery Charging

As expected, the Optimus version helps out with increasing the battery life since the dedicated NVS 3100M graphics card is automatically turned off under light use.

If you take ridiculous measures to save energy and turn the screen brightness down to the minimum, turn off the WiFi and choose the Energy-Saver profile while squinting at your screen and not changing a thing, the notebook would run on battery power for a maximum of almost 10.5 hours.  That is to say, those are the results of the BatteryEater tool's Reader's Test.  The previously reviewed T510 model without Optimus graphics card switching technology endured just over 7 hours in this test.

In the typical-use tests, a similar result can be seen.  Using the internet through WiFi at a screen brightness of 12 out of 15 with the Energy-Saver profile activated, the battery dies after just more than 7 hours, that is, about 3 hours more than the non-Optimus model.

Under heavier use, the advantage of Optimus thins out.  In the DVD test, we were able to stuff our faces with popcorn for only 3 hours 20 minutes with the brightness turned all the way up, barely longer than with the other model.

Finally, in the BatteryEater Classic test with maximum screen brightness, WiFi turned on and in the High-Performance profile, the tables actually turn and the non-Optimus version has the longer battery life.  The cause of this might be the brighter screen of the model in review here.  The minimum battery life also marks the only battery life test with both the GMA and NVS 3100 graphics cards activated and came out to (107 vs. 115 minutes).

Battery Runtime
Idle (without WLAN, min brightness)
10h 25min
WiFi Surfing
7h 11min
DVD
3h 20min
Load (maximum brightness)
1h 47min

The measurements regarding energy consumption weigh heavily in favor of the Optimus version.  These measurements were performed with the GMA HD card on under light use and with the NVS 3100M on under heavy use.  Under light use, our Optimus model uses about 2 watts less than the other non-Optimus model.  What's also nice is that the notebook does not pass the 0.5 watt mark in stand-by mode.

Power Consumption

Off / Standby 0.5 / 0.5 Watt
Idle 11.7 / 20.8 / 24 Watt
Load 54.5 / 71.7 Watt
 
Key: min: , med: , max:         Voltcraft VC 940 Plus

Verdict

Optimus or no Optimus, that is the question.  'Tis no nobler in the case or the selection of ports—that remains the same.  But the Optimus graphics card switching technology finally housed within the Lenovo Thinkpad T510-4384-GEG model means a considerably longer battery life under light use as compared to the non-Optimus T510-4349-4JG model.    Under heavier use, the advantage of Optimus isn't as great and the non-Optimus model actually comes out on top by a little in terms of minimum battery life.  

Aside from the display, the two laptops are identical in terms of hardware except for small differences in the RAM and HDD, bringing about no significant differences in the performance tests.  The Optimus model does emit a bit more system noise but keeps the case cooler for it.  

Another plus of the in-review laptop compared to the previously reviewed T510 is the bright full-HD screen with a broad color space (RGB LED), the same one as in the Thinkpad W510.  The non-reflective, matte screen exhibits a high brightess that's well distributed across the screen and an excellent contrast ratio.

Lenovo has put together a great package for a well-rounded office notebook  with modest 3D graphics potential.  The matte screen with a broad color space and high resolution lends itself well to photo editing while remaining convenient for use in the office or outdoors. 

By courtesy of ...
In Review: Lenovo ThinkPad T510 - 4384-GEG, available at:
In Review: Lenovo ThinkPad T510 - 4384-GEG, available at:

Specifications

Lenovo ThinkPad T510 - 4384-GEG

:: Processor
:: Mainboard
Intel QM57 Express Chipset
:: Memory
4096 MB, DDR3 PC3-10700 (667 MHz)
:: Graphics adapter
NVIDIA NVS 3100M - 512 MB, Core: 606 MHz, Memory: 790 MHz, nvlddmkm 8.17.12.5738 (ForceWare 257.38)/Win 7 64
:: Display
15.6 inch 16:9, 1920x1080 pixel, glossy: no
:: Harddisk
Seagate Momentus 7200.4 ST9500420AS, 500 GB 7200 rpm
:: Soundcard
Conexant Cx20585
:: Connections
1 Express Card 34mm, 4 USB 2.0, 1 Firewire, 1 VGA, 1 DisplayPort, 1 Modem, 1 Kensington Lock, 1 eSata, 1 Docking Station Port, Audio Connections: Kombi-Audio-Buchse, Card Reader: 5-in-1,
:: Networking
Intel 82577LM Gigabit Network Connection (10/100/1000MBit), Intel Centrino Ultimate-N 6300 AGN (a g n ), 2.1 Bluetooth, Qualcomm Gobi 2000 HS-USB Modem 9205
:: Optical drive
HL-DT-ST DVDRAM GT30N
:: Size
height x width x depth (in mm): 40 x 373 x 279
:: Weight
2.81 kg Power Supply: 0.45 kg
:: Battery
94 Wh Lithium-Ion, 9-cell, 11.1 V, 8.4 Ah
:: Price
1800 Euro
:: Operating System
Microsoft Windows 7 Professional 64 Bit
:: Additional features
Webcam: 2.0 MP, Brief Instructions, Troubleshooting, ThinkVantage Tools, Lenovo Online Data Backup, Burn.Now Lenovo Edition, InterVideo WinDVD, Corel Movie Factory 7, MS Office 2007 Trial, MS Research AutoCollage Touch 2009, MS SQL-Server 2005, 36 Months Warranty, 2-in-1 eSATA + USB 2.0 Combination Port; 1 powered USB 2.0 Port

 

Similar Devices

Notebooks from a different Manufacturer and/or with a different CPU

Notebooks with the same GPU

» Review Lenovo Thinkpad T410 2522-3FG Notebook
Core i7 620M, 14.1", 2.31 kg

Laptops with Same Screen Size and/or Weight

» Dell Precision M2800 Notebook Review
FirePro W4170M, Core i7 4810MQ
» Lenovo G510 (59416358) Notebook Review Update
Radeon R5 M230, Core i5 4200M

Links

Price Comparison

Pro

+Time-tested Thinkpad design
+Trackpoint pointing stick
+Keyboard
+Excellent office performance and up-to-date hardware
+Longer battery life under light use thanks to Optimus
+Full-HD screen with broad color space
+Matte, bright screen
+Excellent contrast
+ThinkVantage tools
 

Cons

-Touchpad
-No recovery DVD or manual

Shortcut

What We Like

The matte full-HD screen with very good brightness—well distributed across the screen, excellent contrast and broad color space.

What We'd Like to See

A current Optimus driver.

What Surprises Us

A device of this price range without necessary accessories like a recovery disk, media drivers, etc.

The Competition

15" notebooks with up-to-date hardware with good features necessary for office use and a full-HD screen with a broad color space are a rare find. Good alternatives are the Dell Latitude E6510, the HP Elitebook 8540p as well as the Workstation version Elitebook 8540w, or you could settle for another more powerful Lenovo, the Thinkpad W510 Workstation.

Ratings

Lenovo ThinkPad T510 - 4384-GEG
12/07/2010 v2
Martina Osztovits

Chassis
85%
Keyboard
90%
Pointing Device
89%
Connectivity
81%
Weight
76%
Battery
89%
Display
90%
Games Performance
63%
Application Performance
89%
Temperature
92%
Noise
78%
Add Points
86%
Average
84%
86%
Office *
Weighted Average

> Notebook / Laptop Reviews and News > Reviews > Archive of our own reviews > Review Lenovo ThinkPad T510 Notebook (Optimus)
Author: Martina Osztovits, 2010-12-21 (Update: 2013-06- 6)