Microsoft issues DMCA takedown of Minecraft-like Steam game, raising copyright debate

If Minecraft seems stale, there are plenty of voxel-based survival alternatives. However, gamers now have one less option, after Microsoft filed a DMCA takedown of Allumeria. Given that many rivals of the Mojang Studios title remain on Steam, critics are rejecting the copyright infringement claim.

Why is Microsoft focusing on Allumeria?

Allumeria developer unomelon provided fans on Discord with a disappointing update. Valve informed the creator that:

Judith Woodward, on behalf of Microsoft Corporation, alleges that Microsoft is the copyright owner of the content found at www.minecraft.net/en-us and that your use of Minecraft content, including but not limited to gameplay and assets, without their authorization infringes their rights.

An attached screenshot allegedly shows undeniable similarities between the indie game and Minecraft. Valve’s policy in these instances is to immediately remove any title to avoid a copyright infringement lawsuit. Unomelon can choose to submit a DMCA-compliant counter-notice. If Microsoft doesn’t begin legal proceedings within 10 days, Allumeria will be relisted.

Even with options, the developer is hesitant to take on the massive corporation without a costly lawyer. Fellow game-makers, like the creator of the unsettling sandbox project, Vintage Story, have voiced their support. Tyron argues that Allumeria utilizes a different programming language and features a unique art style.

Too similar to Minecraft?

Some observers view the Steam game as more of a clone than Hytale. The demo trailer showcases textures and an interface that closely resemble Minecraft. On the other hand, unomelon drew inspiration from Terraria, focusing on combat and progression. Players can also customize blocks without needing mods.

Gamers who find the DMCA takedown unjustified note that all voxel games look alike to some degree. Yet, Microsoft seems to be targeting this particular indie title. One explanation is that, lacking human oversight, an AI tool incorrectly flagged Allumeria. That could provide hope for its future, but Microsoft may also have a more convincing explanation for the action.