Fans slam mixed Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake review for lowering Metacritic score

Near universally positive Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake reviews have resulted in an impressive 95 Metascore. The Switch 2 game is the aggregator's top-rated title for 2026, but it was even higher before a Slant Magazine evaluation. With the only mixed rating at 3.5/5 (70/100), fans accuse the site of submitting a low score to draw attention.
Slant published its article a week after the Ocarina of Time remake review embargo expired, and the release date had passed. That allows it to stand out from the 116 Metacritic scores posted. Since a consensus was already established, the 70 mark slightly lowered the average. Nevertheless, it irks some Nintendo supporters that it dropped from 96 to 95.
The magazine has a reputation for bucking trends. It gave Zelda: Breath of the Wild a 60, while the Metacritic average is 97. It was somewhat more generous with Red Dead Redemption 2, although the 70 rating is still well below the 97 Metascore. Most noticeable was the 40 issued to the 2019 Game of the Year Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice.
Too many remakes?
Every player is entitled to an opinion, even with a critical favorite like the latest modernized Zelda. Yet Redditors argue Slant is penalizing the Switch 2 game for a broader industry trend. Nintendo has become increasingly reliant on remakes, as is the case with other publishers.
In the Ocarina of Time review, the writer questions whether another version of the N64 release was necessary. After a 2011 3DS port, it was added to the current-gen console’s Switch Online catalog. However, Cole Kronman seems to undercut his own point about why it may not be worth buying. He compliments the revamped graphics, smoother combat, and faithful adaptation of the classic.
Kronman also angered Zelda loyalists by claiming the original was only occasionally fun. Regardless, Metacritic readers can counter any objectionable ratings with their own opinions. Surviving review bombing, the Switch 2 version of Ocarina of Time beats every competitor on the site, boasting a 9.6 score.




















