Notebookcheck

Apple's T2 chip could severely limit the possibilities of third-party Mac repair

The Apple T2 chip has earned a lot of criticism from right-to-repair advocates. (Source: iFixit)
The Apple T2 chip has earned a lot of criticism from right-to-repair advocates. (Source: iFixit)
Apple has confirmed to The Verge that its T2 chip will limit the ability to repair new Macs as it feels that the chip is crucial to enabling modern security features on Mac computers. However, critics are concerned that Apple's move will greatly impact enthusiasts and third-party repair shops thereby preventing them from offering aftermarket services to Mac owners.

The T2 chip found in modern Mac computers acts as a security measure as it helps process Touch ID fingerprint data, enables secure boot, prevents the MacBook's microphones from being hacked when the lid is closed, and also enables the computer to respond to 'Hey Siri' voice commands. However, critics are getting increasingly worried that Apple could use the T2 chip to effectively shut down DIY enthusiasts and third-party Mac repair shops who will no longer be able to use non-Apple components to get a defective Mac working again.

Apple has confirmed to The Verge that certain components such as the logic board and Touch ID require Apple-authorized parts and that the T2 chip helps in checking the authenticity of the replacement parts at boot. It did not, however, provide the full list of components that the T2 actually communicates with. Apple also did not comment on when this checking mechanism was actually introduced.

Early last month, we reported on a leaked Apple document that detailed how only Apple Authorized Service Providers (AASPs) who have access to Apple Service Toolkit 2 (AST2) can perform repairs and component replacements on new Apple devices with the T2 co-processor. The T2 chip performs a check during post-repair boot and the AASP then runs AST2 on the repaired Mac to communicate to the Apple Global Service Exchange (GSX) server that the new parts are genuine. A negative feedback from the GSX server renders the machine inoperable. 

In an email to The Verge, iFixit CEO Kyle Weins opined that "the T2 is a guillotine that [Apple is] holding over product owners". Wiens goes on to say, "It's very possible the goal is to exert more control over who can perform repairs by limiting access to partsThis could be an attempt to grab more market share from the independent repair providers. Or it could be a threat to keep their authorized network in line. We just don’t know."

According to the leaked document that we spoke about earlier, components such as the display assembly, logic board, top case, and Touch ID board in case of the MacBook Pro, and the logic board and flash storage in case of the iMac Pro require T2 authentication. Apple since has confirmed to The Verge that the display assembly will not require the AST2 tool to be run. The document did not cover the newly announced Mac Mini and MacBook Air as they weren't announced back then. Nevertheless, we know that they incorporate the T2 chip as well. 

However, it seems that this 'kill switch' isn't active yet, at least as of last month. iFixit tried replacing the screen of a 2018 MacBook Pro and even tried swapping logic boards but the notebook seemed to work just fine. Probably a future software update might make AST2 diagnostics mandatory for repairs, we do not know. 

From Apple's perspective, it could be that such a requirement will protect customers from being overcharged by third-party repair shops and ensure that they are not cheaping out on components. Also, since the T2 controls most security functions on newer Macs, the diagnostics will likely ensure that the chip's security functions are not compromised as a result of repairs to the logic board or Touch ID sensor. Right-to-repair advocates, however, feel that this is Apple's way of exerting muscle power and grab a sizeable chunk of the DIY Mac repair market

The problem is not in Apple's policy per se, but in the manner the company has handled the communication (or lack thereof) in this regard — not too unlike the whole throttling iPhone fiasco.

Do you think the Apple T2 chip is a necessary evil? Let us know in the comments below.

Source(s)

static version load dynamic
Loading Comments
Comment on this article
Please share our article, every link counts!
> Notebook / Laptop Reviews and News > News > News Archive > Newsarchive 2018 11 > Apple's T2 chip could severely limit the possibilities of third-party Mac repair
Vaidyanathan Subramaniam, 2018-11-13 (Update: 2018-11-13)
Vaidyanathan Subramaniam
Vaidyanathan Subramaniam - News Editor
I am a cell and molecular biologist and computers have been an integral part of my life ever since I laid my hands on my first PC which was based on an Intel Celeron 266 MHz processor, 16 MB RAM and a modest 2 GB hard disk. Since then, I’ve seen my passion for technology evolve with the times. From traditional floppy based storage and running DOS commands for every other task, to the connected cloud and shared social experiences we take for granted today, I consider myself fortunate to have witnessed a sea change in the technology landscape. I honestly feel that the best is yet to come, when things like AI and cloud computing mature further. When I am not out finding the next big cure for cancer, I read and write about a lot of technology related stuff or go about ripping and re-assembling PCs and laptops.