Notebookcheck

Activision cancelled its WoW: Shadowlands stream to “make space for other voices.” Where was that space when Blitzchung and Hong Kong needed it?

Hearthstone Grandmaster Blitzchung speaking out about the Hong Kong protests (Image source: The Verge)
Hearthstone Grandmaster Blitzchung speaking out about the Hong Kong protests (Image source: The Verge)
Activision Blizzard recently announced that it would be delaying its World of Warcraft: Shadowlands livestream to make way for “more important voices.” However, the decision appears insincere, especially in light of Blizzard’s treatment of Hearthstone Grandmaster Blitzchung for speaking out about the Hong Kong protests.
Arjun Krishna Lal,
Views, thoughts, and opinions expressed in the text belong solely to the author.

Apparently, Activision Blizzard - publishers of everything from Call of Duty to Sekiro to Spyro the remastered purple dragon - recently realised that it had a responsibility to let important voices be heard.

Activision Blizzard cancelled their World of Warcraft: Shadowlands livestream today, stating in a Tweet that "more important voices than ours need to be heard, and now is the time to listen."

In light of the ongoing US protests against police violence and systemic racism, many companies have been postponing events to ensure that they don't detract from what events that matter right now. However, in light of its history, Activision Blizzard's decision is insincere at best.

Not even a year ago, Blizzard was embroiled in controversy during the Hong Kong democracy protests. In a post-match interview, Blitzchung, a professional Hearthstone player from Hong Kong, said "Liberate Hong Kong, the revolution of our times."

This comment was in relation to mass protests in Hong Kong - attended by nearly 2 million people - against Chinese laws potentially infringing on the territory's autonomy and democratic institutions.

Blizzard's response was to ban Blitzchung from the ongoing Hearthstone Grandmasters' tournament, prohibit him from participating in other Grandmasters' tournaments for a year, and to force him to forfeit US$4000 in prize money.

The punishment prompted five US Senators and Members of the House of Representatives who wrote a letter stating that the move could "have a chilling effect on gamers who seek to use their platform to promote human rights and basic freedoms." The letter was addressed to Activision Blizzard CEO Bobby Kotick, someone who Activision shareholders claimed was being “paid too much.” 

Blizzard's reaction to the US protests and their harsh crackdown on Blitzchung is a study in contrasts.

In both cases, people were protesting to protect rights that were democratically guaranteed to them. In one case, Blizzard went so far as to cancel its own World of Warcraft livestream to make space.

In the other case, they disqualified a Hearthstone Grandmaster for saying eight words in an interview.

Blizzard isn't the only company that's trying to accommodate voices of protest. Sony recently postponed a PlayStation 5 livestream for this exact reason.

In Blizzard's case though, one question has to be asked: why couldn't Blizzard find space for the voice of Blitzchung and the voices of Hong Kong?

Hearthstone's Chinese player base is the largest in the world, according to the CEO of Netease. In terms of the number of professional players, China is second only to the United States. Moreover, Tencent - a Chinese company that actively contributes to government surveillance efforts - has a five percent stake in Activision.

The freedom of speech and assembly are enshrined in the First Amendment to the US constitution. As a single-party authoritarian state, China offers no such protection.

While Blizzard claimed that their "relationships in China had no influence on our decision," the large Chinese market and differing opinions on freedom of speech go a long way towards addressing why Blizzard may have acted the way it did when it came to Hong Kong and Blitzchung.

Read all 21 comments / answer
static version load dynamic
Loading Comments
Comment on this article
Please share our article, every link counts!
> Notebook / Laptop Reviews and News > News > News Archive > Newsarchive 2020 06 > Activision cancelled its WoW: Shadowlands stream to “make space for other voices.” Where was that space when Blitzchung and Hong Kong needed it?
Arjun Krishna Lal, 2020-06- 8 (Update: 2020-06- 8)
Comment by Arjun Krishna Lal
Views, thoughts, and opinions expressed in the text belong solely to the author.
Arjun Krishna Lal
Arjun Krishna Lal - News Editor
I've had a passion for PC gaming since 1996, when I watched my dad score frags in Quake as a 1 year-old. I've gone on to become a Penguin-published author and tech journalist. When I'm not traveling the world, gathering stories for my next book, you can find me tinkering with my PC.