Review Dell Inspiron 17R Notebook

Shao-Hung Liu, 07/01/2010

Inspiron 17R(eloaded). Dell's Inspiron 17 has already been available for a while and probably belongs to the American manufacturer's top sellers. Now there is a refresh available, called Inspiron 17R, which can be individually configured as typical for Dell - starting with the color up to hardware configuration.

Our 17.3 inch sized test device is equipped with a Core i5 430M processor that has two cores, both clocked with 2.27 GHz each. Additionally, an ATI Mobility GPU, type Radeon HD 5470 (1024 MB dedicated GDDR3 graphics memory) is used, which rounds off the system as a starter midrange graphic card. There is also a total of four GB DDR3 RAM and a 500 MB sized hard disk, which should provide enough capacity to start with. Microsoft's Windows 7 Home Premium in its 64 bit version is installed as the operating system.

Sections that are strongly dependent on the used hardware, such as performance, emissions and battery life, aren't necessarily true for differently equipped models.

Case

Dell Inspiron 17R in Tomato Red
Dell Inspiron 17R in Tomato Red

The case is an eye catcher in any event. At least, our model at hand, with a red display lid with a high gloss finish is. However, the Inspiron 17R will also be available in other colors so that every potential buyer will hopefully find a suiting finish. If you look at the US site, the Inspiron 17R is available in three colors to date. Dell calls these Mars Black, Tomato Red and Peacock Blue. The Mars Black cover will likely adorn the Inspiron 17R ex-factory, which will be launched on June 24th. If you'd like to have your Inspiron 17R in Tomato Red or Peacock Blue, you'll be charged with $40.00 extra, according to the US site. However, the customers in Germany may look forward to picking a color without a surcharge at the moment.
Dell's well-known logo has been placed on the display's back center. The position of both hinges is another striking feature, as they have been positioned slightly towards the front so that the base unit's rear part protrudes a bit when closed. The Inspiron 17R, with its 17.3 inch display, does quite well without a complicated closing mechanism. Opening and closing is easy, without either hinge emitting audible noise. The display is kept sufficiently in position after a slight teetering.

There's not much to complain about in terms of stability. Especially, the wrist-rest and the area around the keyboard appear to be very resistant against selective pressure. This is partly due to the chrome component into which the keyboard has been submerged. The rest of the case is made of plastic and also makes a quite solid impression so that a lopsided picking up is possible, despite the size of 17.3 inches and a weight of 3.1 kilograms.
All surfaces are rather glossy, with exception of the touchpad. The wrist-rest has been treated to a brushed silver finish, which reduces visible fingerprints on its surface considerably - contrarily to the display lid's very sensitive, red, high-gloss surface also in a brushed look.
If you look for loudspeakers on the upper side, you'll be looking in vain on the Inspiron 17 because they have been placed on the case's lower front area. If you want to equip your Inspiron 17R with more RAM, you'll only need a bit of intuition and a suitable screw driver. By removing the cover, which is only fastened with one screw, you can access the RAM components quite easily.

Configuration

Connectivity

In terms of connectivity, the most important ports are onboard. However, we do miss an ExpressCard slot, for example. We can't complain about the distribution of the existing interfaces. They have been distributed feasibly over three sides.

Thus, we find a USB 2.0 port, the vent, audio input and output, a HDMI port and a cardreader on the left.
Most of the Inspiron 17R's rear is occupied by the mobile power donor. Nevertheless, the rear still has enough place for the power socket, a further USB 2.0 port, an analog VGA out and the third USB 2.0 port.
The optical drive, followed by a USB and eSATA combo port, the RJ-45 network socket and the Kensington lock, is found on the right side.
The front remains unfettered from interfaces.

Left: USB, fan, 2 audio sockets, HDMI, cardreader
Left: USB, fan, 2 audio sockets, HDMI, cardreader
Rear: DC-in, USB, battery, analog VGA, USB
Rear: DC-in, USB, battery, analog VGA, USB
Right: DVD drive, eSATA/USB, LAN, Kensington lock
Right: DVD drive, eSATA/USB, LAN, Kensington lock

Communication

The Inspiron 17R has three options available for communicating with other devices or the internet: the classical LAN port (Atheros AR8152 PCI-E Fast Ethernet Controller), a WLAN module (Broadcom Virtual Wireless adapter) and Bluetooth.
The webcam integrated in the display, with its array microphone allowing for uncomplicated video telephony via Skype and similar programs, is also of assistance in communication matters.

Input Devices

Keyboard

We liked the built-in keyboard already at first sight. It even made a good impression at a closer look and in practical use. The pressure point is very distinct and gives a very comfortable feeling while typing. As it's appropriate for a 17.3 inch notebook, a full sized number pad is onboard.
The manufacturer, Dell, has waived on a multimedia bar and has implemented it into the keyboard. Thus, the F7 to F12 keys have been strikingly marked in an outstanding color with the correlating multimedia icons.

Just as striking: the F-key's small lettering has been placed in the right corner. Dell has given priority to the notebook control keys for brightness, touchpad, display or multimedia keys. Viz. no FN key combination has to be used to, for example, reduce brightness or turn on the WLAN module, as it is the case in most other notebooks. That's only necessary if you actually need the F-key commands, like e.g. help with F1 or the renaming of a file with the F2 key. We admit that this is a bit awkward in the beginning, but you come to appreciate this modification quickly.

Touchpad

Even the touchpad does its work mainly quite well and precisely. The smooth surface feels nice and distinguishes itself from the brushed aluminum wrist-rest with a dark gray.
Otherwise, the touchpad works very accurately and also responds very well to our gestures, such as zooming in and out, scrolling or rotating pictures, etc. Both mouse keys are also made of chrome, like the wrist-rest and do their work to our satisfaction.

Keyboard
Keyboard
Touchpad
Touchpad

Display

The utilized display especially stands out with its very good display brightness, which it revealed in our measurements. The Inspiron 17 refresh has a good position with an average display brightness of 294.44 cd/m2. Merely the display's illumination could be a bit more balanced, in our opinion. The display illumination's imbalance isn't noticeable in practical use, though.

The supplied image quality is just as good, as it provides full and rich colors due to the glare type display (17.3" HD+ (1600 x 900) WLED display with TrueLife). The Inspiron 17R is well equipped with a native resolution of 1600x900, but a display with a higher resolution wouldn't have hurt, especially in times of BluRay and FullHD.

280
cd/m²
273
cd/m²
274
cd/m²
232
cd/m²
256
cd/m²
252
cd/m²
217
cd/m²
240
cd/m²
221
cd/m²
Information
Maximum: 280 cd/m²
Average: 249.4 cd/m²
Brightness Distribution: 78 %
Black: 1.34 cd/m²
Contrast: 191:1
Distribution of brightness

The main point of critique is the high black value of 1.34 cd/m2. Dark, black movie scenes make a rather dark gray impression due to that. In the one or other movie the black weakness is quite obviously noticeable and thus a bit of the atmosphere is lost.

The glossy display considerably hampers an outdoor use, but it's not completely impossible due to the good display brightness. But only in shadowy places since the display doesn't have a chance in direct sunlight, despite its good brightness the displayed image suffers under massive reflections.

On the issue of viewing angles, the horizontal viewing angles are quite generous, but the vertical plane looks very different. Unfortunately, contrast deviations already turn up at a slight change in the opened display or the seating height.

Referenzblick
Blickwinkel
Blickwinkel
Blickwinkel
Blickwinkel
Blickwinkel
Blickwinkel
Blickwinkel

Performance

In the Inspiron 17 refresh, Dell has equipped the Inspiron 17R with Intel's newest CPU generation. This is the Core i processors. Our test device is equipped with a Core i5 430M, which has two cores that do their work with a clock rate of 2.27 GHz. These two core are able to manage up to four threads simultaneously due to HT (Hyper Threading). The Core i5 430M also has the Turbo Boost feature, which can shut down unused cores to save energy and automatically lift the core rate up to 2.53 GHz when additional performance is needed at the same time. Thus, the CPU supplies more than enough computing power to manage daily tasks comfortably and with reserves.
The benchmark assessments that we made with Cinebench R10 and PCMark Vantage confirm this also. Thus, the Inspiron 17R achieved a rating of a reasonable 4884 (5754 points) in PCMark Vantage 32 bits (respectively 64 bits).

System info CPUZ CPU
System info CPUZ Cache
System info CPUZ Mainboard
System info CPUZ RAM
System info CPUZ RAM SPD
System info CPUZ RAM SPD
System info GPUZ
System info HDTune
System information Dell Inspiron 17R

There is also an ATI Mobility Radeon HD 5470 with a 1024 MB GDDR3 memory onboard, tethered to only 64 bits. The Inspiron 17R has enough computing performance to display more current games smoothly with this starter midrange graphic card, with losses in terms of resolution and graphic details. However, the built-in GPU is too weak for high-end gaming in full graphic beauty and resolution. This chip is also capable of DirectX 11 and is manufactured in a 40nm process, which is beneficial for the TDP (Thermal Design Power) and ultimately for the battery life, too.

Cinebench R10 Rendering Single 32Bit
2748
Cinebench R10 Rendering Multiple CPUs 32Bit
6411
Cinebench R10 Shading 32Bit
4317
Cinebench R10 Rendering Single CPUs 64Bit
3371 Points
Cinebench R10 Rendering Multiple CPUs 64Bit
7554 Points
Cinebench R10 Shading 64Bit
4298 Points
Cinebench R11.5 OpenGL 64Bit
10.2 fps
Cinebench R11.5 CPU Multi 64Bit
2 Points
Help
PC Mark
PCMark Vantage5754 points
Help
4.9
Windows 7 Experience Index
Processor
Calculations per second
6.6
Memory (RAM)
Memory operations per second
5.9
Graphics
Desktop performance for Windows Aero
4.9
Gaming graphics
3D business and gaming graphics
5.3
Primary hard disk
Disk data transfer rate
5.7
3D Mark
3DMark 2001SE19805 points
3DMark 039725 points
3DMark 056687 points
3DMark 06
 1280x1024
3627 points
3DMark Vantage1260 points
Help
3DMark Vantage in comparison
Lenovo Thinkpad X100e - 2876-27G (min)
 MV-40, Radeon HD 3200
98
   ...
Lenovo IdeaPad Z565-4311
 N830, Mobility Radeon HD 5470
1246
Sony Vaio VPCEA1S1E/W
 330M, Mobility Radeon HD 5145
1248
Samsung R540-JS08DE
 370M, Mobility Radeon HD 545v
1249
Dell Inspiron 17R
 430M, Mobility Radeon HD 5470
1260
HP Envy 4-1000sg
 2367M, HD Graphics 3000
1264
Acer Aspire V5-122P-61454G50NSS
 A6-1450, Radeon HD 8250
1272
Sony Vaio SVT1311M1ES
 2367M, HD Graphics 3000
1273
   ...
Schenker XMG U702 (max)
 3960X, GeForce GTX 680M SLI
36739
500 GB - 5400 rpm
Transfer Rate Minimum: 9.2 MB/s
Transfer Rate Maximum: 80.7 MB/s
Transfer Rate Average: 57.2 MB/s
Access Time: 19.7 ms
Burst Rate: 85 MB/s

Dell has built-in a 500 GB sized Scorpio Blue hard disk from Western Digital (WD5000BEVT) as the mass memory unit, which does its job with 5400 revolutions in the Inspiron 17R at hand. According to HDTune, its rates are within a green field. If this is too little, you can help yourself with external hard disks due to the USB and eSATA port(s) or order a bigger/faster hard disk to start with.

Gaming Performance

Wie wir testen - Leistung

As already mentioned above, the Inspiron 17R's gaming capacities are a bit limited, despite the use of the latest technologies. Not least by the built-in midrange GPU from ATI, which simply has too little performance reserves to render high resolution images with high graphic details. The Inspiron 17R range hadn't been intended for this, either. If you put value on a high gaming performance, you should take a look at the stronger models from Alienware. A chart of the latest high-performance graphic card can be found following this link on our site. You'll also find detailed information about the ATI Mobility Radeon HD 5470, which has been used our test system.

We tested the real time strategy game, World in Conflict, and the still very resource hungry first person shooter, Crysis, on the Inspiron 17R. World in Conflict runs smoothly in the settings low and medium, which changes abruptly in the setting high (DirectX 10). If it was an average of 79 or 37 fps before, the frame rates drop to a modest 17 fps in high settings.
A smooth gaming course is only possible in low setting in the first-person shooter, Crysis. Lifting the details to medium already cause the frame rate to drop under the 30fps limit at which the human eye perceives the game play as intermittent.

If you would like to find out more about the Mobility Radeon HD 5470's gaming performance, you should definitely take a closer look at the reviews about the Acer Aspire 5740G, the Aspire 7740G or the Asus K52JR-SX059V. Our gaming list of mobile graphic cards also provides information.

low med.high ultra
World in Conflict - Benchmark (2007) 793717fps
Crysis - GPU Benchmark (2007) 62.6725.2813.74fps
Crysis - CPU Benchmark (2007) 50.8622.4311.69fps

Emissions

System Noise

The Inspiron 17R can't exactly be called quiet in view of noise emissions. Our gauge predominantly showed a very good rate with 30.2 dB(A) in idle mode, but the fan turned up periodically. Our measuring instrument reacted and presented us with a considerably louder and audible 35.9 dB(A).
The fan noise reaches up to 44.6 dB(A) under load, which we would definitely call loud.

Noise Level

Idle 30.2 / 30.2 / 35.9 dB(A)
HDD 31.5 dB(A)
DVD 38.1 / 31.5 dB(A)
Load 42.9 / 44.6 dB(A)
 
    30 dB
silent
40 dB
audible
50 dB
loud
 
min: , med: , max:     (15 cm distance)

Temperature

The fans may work within a very audible range, but the result is impressive in the end. The upper side reaches a maximum of 41.5 degrees Celsius in the upper left corner in stress situation, which is still very much within a green field. The notebook doesn't exceed 40 degrees in the other areas.
The temperatures even seem to be alright on the bottom. Thus, the warmest spot in the central area is even a bit cooler than the upper side with 41 degrees. The other areas also stay fairly cool and below the 40 degree Celsius limit.
The base unit's upper side remains almost cool in office mode with temperatures a bit over 30°C.

Max. Load
 41.5 °C38.3 °C26.6 °C 
 39 °C38.5 °C25.7 °C 
 33.5 °C26.6 °C24 °C 
 
26.2 °C34.3 °C39.9 °C
27.9 °C41 °C38.5 °C
24.2 °C27.3 °C28.2 °C
Maximum: 41.5 °C
Average: 32.6 °C
 Maximum: 41 °C
Average: 31.9 °C
Power Supply (max.)  61.7 °C | Room Temperature 21 °C

Loudspeakers

If you look for the loudspeakers in the wrist-rest area or above the keyboard, you'll be looking in vain on the Inspiron 17R because they are in the front area of the base unit's bottom. An integrated sub-woofer built-in ex-factory is supposed to supply more power, especially in the lower ranges. According to the label, an SRS Premium Sound System is concealed underneath the hood, in combination with a Realtek ALC269 @ Intel Ibex Peak PCH - High Definition Audio Controller. The acoustic performance that is ultimately revealed is definitely worth seeing, or better said, worth hearing.

The rendered music tracks even stay static-free and clear at maximum volume, without any distortions or overloading. Basses are also well audible due to the sub-woofer, even if it could use a bit more volume.
Basically, we can issue a good report for the built-in sound system, especially in comparison to the otherwise common sound systems in notebooks.

Battery Life

Readers Test
Maximum battery life (Readers Test)
Classic Test
Minimum battery life (Classic Test)

The Inspiron 17R will likely rather find stationary use as a DTR. Nevertheless, a certain amount of mobility can't hurt. The included 6 cell lithium ion battery has a capacity of 48 Wh (11.1 volts and 4140 mAh).
Our test device achieved a rather moderate result of exactly 60 minutes with maximum display brightness and enabled WLAN, under continuous load via BatteryEater in the classic run. The mobile energy donator reached 235 minutes in the BatteryEater Reader's run, with maximum energy savings options, minimum display brightness and disabled communication units. This would still equal up to three hours and 55 minutes.
You'll have to look for mains after about 208 minutes (3h:28min) when surfing on the internet in battery mode.
The lithium ion battery lasts for a bit more than two hours as a multimedia center used for playing a DVD - 126 minutes to be more precise. Thus, a two hour movie should come to its end with a fully charged battery.

Battery runtime
Idle (without WLAN, min brightness)
3h 55min
WiFi Surfing
3h 28min
DVD
2h 06min
Load (maximum brightness)
1h 00min

Power consumption

Off / Standby 0.1 / 0.4 Watt
Idle 12.3 / 16.7 / 18.7 Watt
Load 55.6 / 75.4 Watt
 
Key: min: , med: , max:         

Verdict

The Inspiron 17R in the configuration at hand, with an Intel Core i5 CPU and ATI Mobility Radeon HD 5470 graphic card, has more than sufficient reserves for daily use. Only losses in terms of resolution and detail levels have to be accepted in games for a smooth game play.

The Inspiron 17R makes a good and solid impression with minor weakness in terms of fan control and noise, which may possibly be eliminated in the configuration with an integrated GPU. In return you are rewarded with a sound system that has an integrated sub-woofer, which is very suitable for rendering music and movies.

Conclusively, we can give the Inspiron 17R a good rating, even if with weaknesses that demanding users have to get used to.

Dell Inspiron 17R
Dell Inspiron 17R
In Review: Dell Inspiron 17R
In Review:  Dell Inspiron 17R

Specifications

Dell Inspiron 17R

:: Processor
:: Mainboard
Intel HM57
:: Memory
4096 MB, DDR3, PC3-10700, Samsung
:: Graphics adapter
ATI Mobility Radeon HD 5470 - 1024 MB, Core: 750 MHz, Memory: 800 MHz, GDDR3, 64 Bit Anbindung, atiumdag 8.14.10.0723 / Win7 64
:: Display
17.3 inch 16:9, 1600x900 pixel, glossy: yes
:: Harddisk
500 GB - 5400 rpm, 500 GB 5400 rpm Scorpio Blue Western Digital
:: Soundcard
Realtek ALC670 @ Intel Ibex Peak PCH - High Definition Audio Controller
:: Connections
4 USB 2.0, 1 VGA, 1 HDMI, 1 Kensington Lock, 1 eSata, Audio Connections: 2 (audio in & out), Card Reader: 1,
:: Networking
Atheros AR8151 PCI-E Gigabit Ethernet Controller (10/100/1000MBit), Broadcom Virtual Wireless Adapter (), 1 Bluetooth
:: Optical drive
Optiarc DVD RW AD-7585H
:: Weight
3.11 kg Power Supply: 0.44 kg
:: Battery
48 Wh Lithium-Ion, 11.1 Volt, 4100mAh
:: Operating System
Microsoft Windows 7 Home Premium 64 Bit
:: Additional features
Webcam: 1, 12 Months Warranty

 

The Dell Inspiron 17R in Tomato Red...
The Dell Inspiron 17R in Tomato Red...
...doesn't only look good...
...doesn't only look good...
...but also has much to offer.
...but also has much to offer.
Dell offers the Inspiron 17R range...
Dell offers the Inspiron 17R range...
...in three colors:
...in three colors:
Mars Black, Tomato Red and Peacock Blue.
Mars Black, Tomato Red and Peacock Blue.
The 17.3 inch sized notebook doesn't only have...
The 17.3 inch sized notebook doesn't only have...
...the most common interfaces...
...the most common interfaces...
...but also a number pad,...
...but also a number pad,...
...a webcam including an array microphone,...
...a webcam including an array microphone,...
...a quality keyboard in combination with a multi-gesture touchpad,...
...a quality keyboard in combination with a multi-gesture touchpad,...
...and a glare type display,...
...and a glare type display,...
...but it also has a very good quality sound system with integrated sub-woofer.
...but it also has a very good quality sound system with integrated sub-woofer.
Dell also builds the latest hardware...
Dell also builds the latest hardware...
...like Intel's Core i5 processor or ATI's Mobility Radeon HD 5470...
...like Intel's Core i5 processor or ATI's Mobility Radeon HD 5470...
...into the Inspiron 17R range.
...into the Inspiron 17R range.

Similar Notebooks

Similar Notebooks from a different Manufacturer

Notebooks from a different Manufacturer and/or with a different CPU

Notebooks with the same GPU

» Review Acer Aspire 5552G Notebook
Athlon II P340, 15.6", 2.498 kg
» Review Lenovo IdeaPad Z565-4311 Notebook
Phenom II X3 N830, 15.6", 2.595 kg
» Review Asus B53J Notebook
Core i5 450M, 15.6", 2.76 kg
» Review Dell Inspiron 15R Notebook
Core i5 430M, 15.6", 2.64 kg

Links

Compare Prices

Dell Inspiron 17R on Ciao

Pro

+Display brightness
+Workmanship & stability
+Sound system with sub-woofer
+Value for money ratio
 

Contra

-Fan control
-Poor black value/contrast

Shortcut

What we like

We quite liked the Inspiron 17R's looks, especially with the different colors optionally available.

What we miss

A display with a higher resolution, preferably FullHD, in combination with a BluRay drive would more than just complement the Inspiron 17R.

What surprises us

The built-in SRS sound system with integrated sub-woofer is very impressive acoustically.

The competitors

The Acer Aspire 7740G with the same GPU and CPU would be a competitor worth mentioning in the 17 inch division. Or even the Asus K52JR-SX059V. There is the Samsung R525 Eikee NP-R525-JS01DE for AMD fans, but from the 15 inch division.

Rating

Dell Inspiron 17R
12/04/2010 v2
Shao-Hung Liu

Chassis
85%
Keyboard
82%
Pointing Device
84%
Connectivity
70%
Weight
71%
Battery
75%
Display
68%
Games Performance
65%
Application Performance
89%
Temperature
85%
Noise
80%
Add Points
82%
Average
78%
77%
Gaming *
Weighted Average

> Notebook / Laptop Reviews and News > Reviews > Archive of our own reviews > Review Dell Inspiron 17R Notebook
Author: Shao-Hung Liu, 2010-07- 1 (Update: 2013-06- 6)