Notebookcheck

Microsoft Surface: Security concerns responsible for the lack of Thunderbolt & upgradable RAM (allegedly)

Microsoft Surface: Security concerns responsible for the lack of Thunderbolt & upgradable RAM (allegedly)
Microsoft Surface: Security concerns responsible for the lack of Thunderbolt & upgradable RAM (allegedly)
The lack of Thunderbolt 3 on Microsoft's Surface Laptops has been a problem for years. Such expensive products are just expected to support this standard. Now a video surfaced where an alleged Microsoft spokesperson names the reason for the lack of Thunderbolt 3 as well as upgradable RAM: Security.
Benjamin Herzig,

Microsoft has engineered some very exciting devices under the Surface brand in the last years. From the original hybrid tablet line Surface Pro to the Surface Book and the Surface Laptop: All of these Microsoft Surface devices have delivered quality designs with great screens, especially since Microsoft switches to the 3:2 aspect-ratio for the screens.

However, as all devices, they are not perfect. If there are two consistent weak-points to be named, one would be a lack of upgradability – Microsoft surface devices have been notoriously hard to repair. Another is the inexplicable lack of Thunderbolt 3. The powerful standard that enables advanced accessories like external GPUs is just not available on any Surface laptop or tablet. Even USB-C was long missing, with Microsoft only recently adopting it instead of the obsolete miniDisplayPort. However, Thunderbolt 3 is still not present.

We may have an explanation as to why that is: In a leaked presentation about the Microsoft Surface Laptop 3, a Microsoft spokesperson explains that Microsoft omitted Thunderbolt 3 out of security concerns. According to him, the port grants direct memory-access, which is a security liability that Microsoft wanted avoid. Security concerns are also the reason why the Surface Laptop 3 lacks upgradable RAM, as someone could freeze the removable RAM stick to read out private data.

Of course, without an official confirmation from Microsoft, this should be taken with a grain of salt. In any case, it would interest us if our readers find this argument convincing or not. After all, leaving out those features has other advantages as well. Thunderbolt 3 chips cost a few dollars per device and upgradable RAM does take up some space compared to a soldered solution.

Read all 15 comments / answer
static version load dynamic
Loading Comments
Comment on this article
Please share our article, every link counts!
> Notebook / Laptop Reviews and News > News > News Archive > Newsarchive 2020 04 > Microsoft Surface: Security concerns responsible for the lack of Thunderbolt & upgradable RAM (allegedly)
Benjamin Herzig, 2020-04-26 (Update: 2020-04-26)
Benjamin Herzig
Benjamin Herzig - Editor
In 2010 I started to get more and more involved with technology, especially notebooks have been my passion ever since. Of course I came across the detailed tests of Notebookcheck very quickly. With time I learned more and more about notebooks and started writing small reviews about notebooks in forums and blog pages. To earn some extra money during my studies I turned my hobby into my profession and joined the team of Notebookcheck in 2016. My personal interest is especially in business notebooks.