Notebookcheck

Review HP Compaq nx9420 Notebook

Big Business light. Also in the business segment there is a trend for 17 inch desktop replacement notebooks. They are appreciated because of their high-resolution displays and the possibility to choose more powerful hardware components which in turn enable the notebook to replace a desktop PC, as the name already implies.

HP Compaq nx9420 Logo

Case

The current Compaq business design is used in the whole HP product range from the smallest 12 inch subnotebooks up to big and powerful  desktop replacements. Rightly, it would be a waste to abandon a good design.

Alike other Compaq notebooks, the HP Compaq nx9420 has a very robust case. Most apparent are the resistance against applied forces and an excellent flexural rigidity. In total the nx9420 does not seem as compact as a  12 or 14 inch notebook, however, this is hardly possible because of its dimensions alone. Even if you pick this slim notebook up at its front edge, you can neither hear any creaking noise nor observe any torsions.

The display is attached by two relatively small hinges. Adapting its position leads to a slight possible see-saw. The display is locked by a ramshorn hook, which protects the display surface from object and dust penetration.

The interfaces of nx9420 had to be mainly placed at both sides. This stems from the location of the battery, which is at the back. Especially at the left side, but also at the right side, the interfaces are, therefore, partly rather near to the front. Should you use this notebook without docking station and also use lots of the interfaces, your workspace is clearly reduced.

Front Side: Cardreader
HP Compaq nx9420 Interfaces
Left Side: Fan, Power Connector, VGA-Out, S-Video, 2x USB 2.0, Firewire, PCCard, Smartcard reader
HP Compaq nx9420 Interfaces
Back Side: Kensington Lock, Battery, Modem
HP Compaq nx9420 Interfaces
Right Side: Audio Ports, 2x USB 2.0, DVD drive, Lan
HP Compaq nx9420 Interfaces

Input Devices

The area for input devices of the Compaq nx9420 is especially spacious and clearly designed. First of all the standard keyboard has keys with an user-friendly size and is clearly structured by separate groups of keys. Furthermore, this notebook provides you with a numeric pad.

The keyboard is tightly attached to the case and using it is comfortable even during longer periods of typing. Because of its overall keyboard layout and the size of the keys, typing mistakes are unlikely.

The touch pad of the nx9420, which is somewhat positioned out of the center of the notebook, however, in the center below the standard keyboard, pleases by precise response and helps precisely moving the mouse pointer on the display. We especially liked the soft-touch pick buttons, which are also comfortable in use.

Above the keyboard there are some hotkeys typical for HP: Activating/Deactivating of the WLan and keys for volume control. The power switch is also at the top side, left, near the back.

Touch pad
HP Compaq nx9420 Touch pad
Keyboard
HP Compaq nx9420 Keyboard

Display

Color Diagram
HP Compaq nx9420 Display Measurement

Two display versions are available for the HP Compaq nx9420. First of all a 17 inch 1440x900 WXGA+ display with matt surface, and also a 1680x1050 WSXGA+ Brightview panel (reflecting surface), which was the one of the notebook we reviewed.

The maximum brightness of the 1680x1050 WSXGA+ displays and also the illumination could not really convince. We measured a maximum brightness of only 132.5 cd/m² and the illumination is moderate at 67.9%, because the brightness clearly diminishes at the left edge.
Furthermore, we detected a kind of bright bar at the surface on the display. It seems that this stems from a gleam of the backlight.

The measurement diagram depicts a nearly ideal green and red color curve. Unfortunately, the blue color curve is as usually lowered, which leads to dominating red colors.

89.9
cd/m²
128.1
cd/m²
113.1
cd/m²
96.9
cd/m²
132.5
cd/m²
113.6
cd/m²
96.5
cd/m²
115.8
cd/m²
103.6
cd/m²
Distribution of brightness
Information
Maximum: 132.5 cd/m²
Average: 110 cd/m²
Brightness Distribution: 68 %
Black: 0.2 cd/m²
Contrast: 663:1

A plus of displays with reflecting surface is their brilliant contrast. We measured a very low black value of  0.2 cd/m² for the nx9420 which resulted in an excellent contrast ratio of 663:1.
The Pixperan test of legibility did not uncover any anomalies regarding speed of reaction.

According to the manufacturer, this display should also be capable of displaying pin-sharp pictures in sunlight. This might well be, but, we doubt that the user is able to recognize them. First of all displays with reflecting surface usually heavily reflect in bright environments. Furthermore, a maximum brightness of 132.5 cd/m² and an even worse average brightness of 110.0 cd/m² indicate that this display is hardly fit for outdoor usage.

Horizontally, the stability to the vantage point is rather good. Depending on the lightening conditions, you might face reflections. Vertically, you can observe a clear change of the picture outside an acceptable area of operation. E.g., looking from top to down results in a heavily diminishing contrast (white turns gray) and looking from bottom to top results in a darkening.

HP Compaq nx9420 Stability to the Vantage Point
HP Compaq nx9420 Stability to the Vantage Point
HP Compaq nx9420 Stability to the Vantage Point
HP Compaq nx9420 Stability to the Vantage Point
HP Compaq nx9420 Stability to the Vantage Point
HP Compaq nx9420 Stability to the Vantage Point
HP Compaq nx9420 Stability to the Vantage Point
HP Compaq nx9420 Stability to the Vantage Point

Performance

In order to also meet desktop demands the HP Compaq nx9420 is available with powerful processors combined with 3D capable video cards. The notebook we reviewed was equipped with a T7400 Core 2 Duo CPU by Intel with 2.16 GHz and a ATI Mobility Radeon X1600 video card.

While there are hardly any improvements possible regarding the processor (maybe a T7600), the chosen video card is rather a middle-class video card. Just 17 inch DTR notebooks are absolutely equipped with more powerful video cards. If you should require first-class video power for 3D applications and CAD, you should rather chose, e.g., a HP nw9440 workstation, which is one of the most powerful HP notebooks.

In any case, the current equipment of the nx9420 still meets the requirements of a lot of application. Office and Internet application are no problem for this notebook. Depending on the desired performance, multimedia applications up to CAD, are yet possible. Even current games should be no problem for the nx9420, however, the resolution should be lowered.

The 120GB Seagate Momentus hard disk with 5400 revs rated slightly above average regarding transfer rates and access times. Alternatively you can also choose a hard disk with 100GB capacity.

Further information about the video card can be found here or in our comparison of mobile video cards. Detailed information about the Core 2 Duo CPU can be found here.

Please also look at our benchmark list of mobile processors or at our benchmark list of mobile video cards, in order to compare this notebook to other configurations.

Benchmark Comparison 3DMark
HP Compaq nx9420 Benchmark Comparison
Benchmark Comparison PCMark
HP Compaq nx9420 Benchmark Comparison
3D Mark
3DMark 053927 points
Help
3DMark 05 in comparison
Nokia Booklet 3G (min)
 Z530, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 500
120
   ...
Packard Bell EasyNote TJ65
 T4300, GeForce G 105M
3922
Dell Latitude E6500
 P9500, Quadro NVS 160M
3923
HP nx9420
 T7400, Mobility Radeon X1600
3927
Apple MacBook Aluminium
 P8600, GeForce 9400M (G) / ION (LE)
3930
Asus Eee PC 1215N
 D525, ION 2
3961
   ...
Alienware M18x R2 (max)
 3920XM, Radeon HD 7970M Crossfire
36878
PC Mark
PCMark 054683 points
Help
PCMark 05 in comparison
Acer Aspire One 751 (min)
 Z520, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 500
692
   ...
Asus PL30JT-RO030X
 520UM, GeForce 310M
4682
Sony Vaio VGN-AR51M
 T7250, GeForce 8400M GT
4683
HP nx9420
 T7400, Mobility Radeon X1600
4683
Apple MacBook Aluminium
 P7350, GeForce 9400M (G) / ION (LE)
4704
Acer Aspire 6920G-814G32Bn
 T8100, GeForce 9500M GS
4715
   ...
Fujitsu Celsius H710 WXP11DE (max)
 2820QM, Quadro 1000M
13842
120 GB - 5400 rpm
Transfer Rate Minimum: 19.3 MB/s
Transfer Rate Maximum: 39.1 MB/s
Transfer Rate Average: 31.5 MB/s
Access Time: 15.9 ms
Burst Rate: 91.8 MB/s
CPU Usage: 2.4 %

Emissions

Loudness

The equipment aims for performance and causes a steadily running fan. The noise is yet alright in idle mode, you can hear the fan, but, rather decent from the background.
Under load the noise can reach up to 43.2 dB, which can be clearly heard and annoy after a while.

Temperature

Generally, there were no anomalies regarding measured temperature emissions. The maximum temperature at the top side of the notebook was 34.7°C and 39.2°C at the bottom side. So, the nx9420's temperature is even under load alright.

Upper side

palmwrist: 31.1°C max: 34.7°C avg: 32.2°C

Bottom side

max: 39.2°C avg: 36.8°C

Speakers

Both of the speakers are at the front edge under covers which look like vent holes. Their sound is alright, however, the sonority, especially the basses, could yet be clearly better. The maximum volume is alright. Overall, the speakers are alright for playing music.

Battery Runtime

Optional external battery
HP nx9420 additional battery

The 68 Wh battery of this notebook provides you with a runtime which is in between a minimum of about 2 hours and a maximum of up to 4 hours. Considering it is a desktop replacement notebook, the runtime of the nx9420 is excellent.

Furthermore, you can use externally docked additional batteries with this notebook, similar to other Compaq notebooks. These are capable of increasing the runtime accordingly by partly very high capacity of up to 95 Wh (Ultra Capacity Battery).

Battery Runtime
Idle (without WLAN, min brightness)
3h 55min
Load (maximum brightness)
2h 00min

Power Consumption

Idle 31.3 / 37.9 / 42.2 Watt
Load 70.3 / 68.6 Watt
 
Key: min: , med: , max:         

Verdict

In general the Hewlett-Packard Compaq nx9420 is a robust and shapely desktop replacement notebook with good performance and excellent input devices. Its main weakness is clearly its reflecting WSXGA+ display.

The case of very good workmanship with first-class quality of materials pleases by a decent business design and includes spacious input devices, like e.g., a separate numeric pad.

As already mentioned above, the display could not really convince us. While the disadvantages of the reflecting surface might need to be put into perspective depending on the planned usage and the preferences of the user, the rather moderate brightness and the poor illumination are clear weaknesses. The vertical stability to the vantage point is, too, rather narrow. Even if we did not review the alternative, a matt 1440x900 pixels WXGA+ display, you should definitely consider choosing it instead.

The performance of the Compaq nx9420 is alright for office oriented applications and also for multimedia applications. The X1600 video card provides the notebook with good 3D capability.

The emissions of the notebook are regarding noise and surface temperature alright and should not annoy the user at all.

Even the battery runtime of the nx9420, which is in between 2 and 4 hours is passable. A number of available external batteries make it even possible to increase the battery runtime further.

HP Compaq nx9420
HP Compaq nx9420
Reviewed: HP Compaq nx9420
HP Compaq nx9420

Specifications

HP nx9420
Graphics adapter
Memory
1024 MB 
, DDR2 PC5300 (667 MHz) SDRAM, max. 4096MB, 1x1024MB
Display
17.0 inch 16:10, 1680x1050 pixel, WSXGA+ TFT Display, glossy: yes
Mainboard
Intel 945PM
Harddisk
120 GB - 5400 rpm, 120 GB 
5400 rpm Seagate Momentus ST9120821AS: 120GB, 5400rpm
Connections
PCCard, SmartCard, Mikrofon, Headphones (Line out), 4x USB 2.0, VGA-Out, S-Video, Kensington Lock, Firewire, LAN, Modem, Docking Connector
Size
height x width x depth (in mm): 33 x 393 x 275 ( = 1.3 x 15.47 x 10.83 in)
Weight
3.3 kg ( = 116.4 oz) ( = 0 oz)
Battery
, 68 Wh (14.4V) Lithium Ionen Akku
Price
1400 Euro
Additional features
HDD: 120GB, 5400rpm, Seagate Momentus ST9120821AS, SoundMAX HD Audio, DVD +/-R (DL) Hitachi-LG GMA-4082N,

 

[+] compare
Despite of its dimensions the HP nx9420 is elegant.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
The heating can be nearly neglected.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
Although the fan runs all the time, its noise is rather decent.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
a use it in many fields of operations possible.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
Thanks to a Core 2 Duo CPU and a X1600 video card, the provided performance of the nx9420 makes...
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
The main weakness is the reflecting display, whose brightness and illumination are rather moderate.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
The keyboard is spacious and has a separate numeric pad.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
Therefore, using a docking station might be useful.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
The nx9420' interfaces are unfortunately rather near the front on both sides.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
Only the hinges did not attach the display absolutely tight.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
Even if you pick it up at the front edge, you won't hear any creaking.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
The whole case is very robust.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
Not only the design, also the workmanship could convince us.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
The design and the relatively slim case contribute to this.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image
Generally alright: Passable runtime provided by a 68 Wh Li-Ion battery.
HP Compaq nx9420 Image

Pro

  • Robustes case, high-quality materials
  • Spacious keyboard with separate numeric pad
  • User-friendly touch pad
  • Moderate noise emissions
  • Low temperature emissions
  • Passable speakers
  • Good battery runtime and external batteries available
  • Contra

  • Moderate stability of the hinges
  • Unreasonable order of interfaces
  • Reflecting display with moderate brightness and poor illumination
  • Similar Notebooks

    Price Comparison

    Ciao HP Compaq nx9420

    Bewertung

    HP nx9420
    08/31/2007
    J. Simon Leitner

    Chassis
    92%
    Keyboard
    92%
    Pointing Device
    90%
    Connectivity
    86%
    Weight
    68%
    Battery
    88%
    Display
    69%
    Games Performance
    85%
    Application Performance
    98%
    Temperature
    77%
    Noise
    81%
    Add Points
    88%
    Average
    85%
    86%
    Gaming *
    Weighted Average
    > Notebook / Laptop Reviews and News > Reviews > Archive of our own reviews > Review HP Compaq nx9420 Notebook
    Author: J. Simon Leitner, 2007-04-26 (Update: 2013-05- 8)