Notebookcheck

Review HP Compaq 8710p Notebook

Quadro Business Power. Also Hewlet-Packard reacted to the progress in CPU development and, especially, also to availability of new video cards by a new business series. The powerful 17" class is today represented by the HP Compaq 8710p and also the 8710w. Equipped with the new-generation Core 2 Duo processors and a NVIDIA Quadro NVS 320M video card this notebook provides top performance, also for 3D applications. More about how this notebook rates in our tests, can be read here.

HP Compaq 8710p Logo

Case

Regarding form and look the successors of the HP nx/nw 9400 series do not differ too much from their predecessors. The black case with blue-gray inlays and a colored display cover persists.

The molding covering the hot keys above the keyboard was slightly redesigned. It is now parallel to the keyboard and nearly the whole width of the case is utilized. Further to the power switch at the left side it also provides a  number of hot keys. What's special is, that the keys themselves are implemented using contact sensitive areas and, so, no further mechanical parts were needed.

The solution does not only look good, each of the keys could also convince in practice. Also the volume control, which makes it possible to adjust the volume by moving the finger over a marked zone, is felicitous.

That's all regarding design. No further changes got obvious. The same is also true regarding robustness and stability of the case. Overall, the HP Compaq 8710p has a good pressure resistance and flexural rigidity. However, there is a small weakness at the right group of four USB ports.

If you pick the notebook up at this part, you can hear a loud creaking noise.  Still, overall workmanship and case stability convince.

The display's pressure resistance and flexural rigidity  is also good. The two hinges allow a slight see-saw after adjusting the big 17" display's position, but, otherwise they seem robust.

The display is locked by a ramshorn hook, if closed. The handy surface of the slider eases the use of the opening mechanism.

The interfaces offered by the HP Compaq 8710p are mainly at the notebooks left and right side and there near the front. There are many interfaces provided, so, utilizing them directly at the notebook will cause cable spaghetti. Especially the four USB ports at the right side could cause problems. Positive is that also a HDMI port is provided at the left side.

Of course the Compaq 8710p also provides a docking port, which allows to move all the provided ports to the back and free the sides from cable spaghetti.

Front Side: CardReader
HP Compaq 8710p Interfaces
Left Side: Kensington Lock, Fan, Power Connector, HDMI, VGA-Out, 2xUSB, Firewire, PCCard, Smartcard
HP Compaq 8710p Interfaces
Back Side: Battery, Fan
HP Compaq 8710p Anschlüsse
Right Side: Audio Ports, 4xUSB, DVD Drive (lightScribe), Modem, LAN
HP Compaq 8710p Interfaces

Input Devices

There were hardly any changes regarding design and typing comfort of the keyboard. The notebook provides a clearly structured keyboard with a numerical pad at the right side..

Overall the size of the keys is alright. A enter key which extends over too rows seems nearly naturally. The cursor block is a little bit separated from the other keys.

In general typing is comfortable, but, seems a little bit jerky, because of the strong point of pressure and a relatively long travel. Fast typing is accompanied by a clearly clicking, nearly rattling noise, although the keyboard is attached tightly to the case, besides, that it yields a litte.

The HP Compaq 8710p provides, additionally to the touch pad, also a blue track point in the middle of the keyboard. Once again the unergonomic surface and the high resistance of the track point are points of critique. So, working with the track point is not very user-friendly.

A nice feature are contact sensitive hot keys above the keyboard. Again, one of the hot keys launches the Windows calculator. This notebook provides the fingerprint reader no longer at the touch pad, but, at the right lower corner of the palm rest areas.

Touch pad
HP Compaq 8710p Touchpad
Keyboard
HP Compaq 8710p Tastatur

Display

Color Diagram
Test HP Compaq 8710p display measurement

Typical HP, also for the Compaq 8710p a variety of display versions is available. They range from a 17“ WXGA+ panel (1440x900) anti-glare, which the reviewed notebook was equipped with, to a WSXGA+ display (1680x1050) available in an anti-glare or a bright-view (reflecting) version.

We felt that the resolution of WXGA+ panel was nearly a little bit to coarse for a 17" display. The WSXGA would provide more overview and would also fit better to a 17 inch notebook.

We measured a very good maximum brightness of 191.4 cd/m² in the center of the display, but, the brightness heavily diminishes near the bottom edges, where we measured only 135.9 cd/m². So, the illumination of the panel is poor at 71.0%.

The minimum brightness of the panel was 0.8 cd/m². Together with the maximum brightness of 191.4 cd/m² this gives a maximum contrast ratio of 239:1. There are no anomalies regarding the display's speed of reaction.

1) measurement 2) measurement
298.2
cd/m²
295.2
cd/m²
298.6
cd/m²
293.0
cd/m²
278.6
cd/m²
297.4
cd/m²
333.4
cd/m²
332.0
cd/m²
345.4
cd/m²
Distribution of brightness
Information
Maximum: 345.4 cd/m²
Average: 308 cd/m²
Brightness Distribution: 81 %
Black: 0.6 cd/m²
Contrast: 464:1
172.4
cd/m²
187.9
cd/m²
176.7
cd/m²
161.4
cd/m²
191.4
cd/m²
166.9
cd/m²
135.9
cd/m²
160.5
cd/m²
145.5
cd/m²
Distribution of brightness
Information
Maximum: 191.4 cd/m²
Average: 166.5 cd/m²
Brightness Distribution: 71 %
Black: 0.8 cd/m²
Contrast: 239:1
Outdoor Betrieb
Test HP Compaq 8710p Outdoor

The outdoor test demonstrates the advantages of the  anti-glare display, because there aren't any reflections.  In general the display was well legible, but, if it was brighter, working outdoors would be even more user-friendly.

Horizontally, regarding stability to the vantage point the area of operation is spaciousVertically, the display darkens or whitens depending on the vantage point outside a sufficiently big area of operation.

Test HP Compaq 8710p Stability to the Vantage Point
Test HP Compaq 8710p Stability to the Vantage Point
Test HP Compaq 8710p Stability to the Vantage Point
Test HP Compaq 8710p Stability to the Vantage Point
Test HP Compaq 8710p Stability to the Vantage Point
Test HP Compaq 8710p Stability to the Vantage Point
Test HP Compaq 8710p Stability to the Vantage Point
Test HP Compaq 8710p Stability to the Vantage Point


Video of Display's Stability to the Vantage Point

Performance

The HP Compaq 8710p is equipped with a powerful Core 2 Duo processor and a NVIDIA Quadro NVS 320M video card. Especially the video card is of interest, even more, because the HP home page categorizes and advertises the HP Compaq 8710p under „Performance Notebooks“.

After the benchmarks were run, the following was clear: The 8710p is indeed a high-performance notebook. It reached top results in the 3D Mark benchmark test and also rates excellent during practical game tests.

According to various information the Quadro NVS 320M chip is based on the Geforce 8600M GT. However, because of the reached benchmark results, you can assume that it is actually a higher-clocked Geforce 8700M GT.

At least the following is for sure: The video card was clocked with 575 MHz GPU and 702 MHz VRAM. This is a  clear increase compared to the 8600M GT chips (475 MHz GPU). Furthermore, the Quadro NVS 320M should be equipped with GDDR3 RAM, in more detail with 512MB VRAM.

However, for the user only the performance of the hardware is interesting, and the HP Compaq NVS 320M's video performance is excellent. Although the the HP Compaq 8710p is actually not intended a  gaming notebook, current games are still applications with high 3D demands and, so, the notebook's game performance is interesting.

Therewith also 3D applications, CAD and graphical design are no problem for the 8710p.

Furthermore, the reviewed notebook was equipped with 2GB main memory and a 160GB hard disk with 5400 revs/min.

Please also look at our benchmark list of mobile processors or at our benchmark list of mobile video cards, in order to compare this notebook to other configurations.

Benchmark Comparison 3DMark
Benchmark Comparison 3DMark
Benchmark Comparison PCMark
Benchmark Comparison PCMark
3D Mark
3DMark 2001SE29508 points
3DMark 0313895 points
3DMark 059070 points
3DMark 06
 
4781 points
Help
3DMark 06 in comparison
Sony Vaio VGN-FS485B (min)
 740, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 900
54
   ...
Samsung 300V3A-S02
 2410M, GeForce GT 520M
4761
Apple MacBook Pro Retina 13 inch 2012-10
 3210M, HD Graphics 4000
4772
HP 8710p
 T7300, Quadro NVS 320M
4781
HP Pavilion g7-1353eg
 A6-3420M, Radeon HD 6520G + HD 7450M Dual Graphics
4786
HP ProBook 650 G1 H5G74E
 4000M, HD Graphics 4600
4795
   ...
Clevo Clevo P157SM (max)
 4930MX, GeForce GTX 880M
29955
PC Mark
PCMark 055095 points
Help
PCMark 05 in comparison
Acer Aspire One 751 (min)
 Z520, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 500
692
   ...
Lenovo IdeaPad V560
 370M, GeForce 310M
5083
Toshiba Tecra M11-104
 330M, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) HD Graphics
5084
HP 8710p
 T7300, Quadro NVS 320M
5095
Samsung P530 Pro
 330M, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) HD Graphics
5107
Dell Latitude E6400
 P8400, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 4500MHD
5125
   ...
Fujitsu Celsius H710 WXP11DE (max)
 2820QM, Quadro 1000M
13842
160 GB - 5400 rpm
Transfer Rate Minimum: 20.8 MB/s
Transfer Rate Maximum: 48.8 MB/s
Transfer Rate Average: 36.9 MB/s
Access Time: 17.9 ms
Burst Rate: 69.4 MB/s
CPU Usage: 2.1 %

Further Benchmark Results:

Supreme Commander
[Test with Skirmish 1 vs 1 on a small map]

  • Resolution 1024x768, Detail Presets: "high" - 30 fps in game - well playable
  • Resolution 1280x800, Detail Presets: "high" - 30 fps in game - well playable
  • Resolution 1440x900, Detail Presets: "high" - 30 fps in game - well playable
  • Resolution 1440x900, all details: max. - 30 fps in game - well playable.
  • Resolution 1440x900, all details: max., AA Level1 - 35 fps in game - well playable.

Command an Conquer III
[Test with Skirmish 1 vs 1 on a small map]

  • Resolution 1024x768, Presets: "high", AA off - 41-60fps, 49 fps in game - well playable.
  • Resolution 1280x800, Presets: "high", AA off - 23-60fps, 38 fps in game - well playable.
  • Resolution 1440x900, Presets: "high", AA off - 18-60fps, 28 fps in game - well playable.
  • Resolution 1440x900, all settings: max., 4xAA - 15-60fps, 20 fps in game - well playable.

Both games are also well playable in the highest listed resolution.

Emissions

Loudness

If you think that such a high-performance notebook must be loud, you err. Especially in idle mode the HP 8710p is very quiet. Once again, the noise of the hard disk is louder than the fan. It's time that the SSD hard disks are improved, so, that it's finally quiet ;-)

Under load the fan audibly speeds up. Although it is clearly audibly, it's noise is not really disturbing. We measured a noise level of up to 45.8 dB under load.

Noise Level

Idle 35.6 / 42.7 / 35.6 dB(A)
HDD 35.8 dB(A)
DVD 37.6 / dB(A)
Load / 45.8 dB(A)
 
    30 dB
silent
40 dB
audible
50 dB
loud
 
min: , med: , max:     (15 cm distance)

Temperature

The surface temperature is without any striking maximums. At the top side the maximum is about 35°C and 40°C at the bottom side. This is alright, even more, if you consider the high performance of the HP Compaq 8710p.

Upper side

palmwrist: 29.4°C max: 36.6°C avg: 32.0°C

Bottom side

max: 40.1°C avg: 36.3°C

Speakers

The sound of the two speakers, located at the front edge of the notebook, is passable. The maximum volume is alright, but, the sound a little bit dull.

The sound output via the analog 3,5mm stereo output was alright too.

Battery Runtime

The big battery with 73Wh capacity reached a good runtime. It ranges from about 2 hours under load to nearly 6 hours with minimum energy demand. This runtime is alright for a DTR notebook with comparable performance.

Furthermore, it is possible to attach supplement batteries at the bottom side of the HP 8710p. For this purpose the notebook provides a dedicated connector beside the docking port. So, it is possible to further increase the battery runtime by external 'high capacity batteries'.

Battery Runtime
Idle (without WLAN, min brightness)
5h 50min
DVD
2h 30min
Load (maximum brightness)
2h 00min

Power Consumption

Idle 13.6 / 17.0 / 19.8 Watt
Load 24.8 / 23.1 Watt
 
Key: min: , med: , max:         

Verdict

HP Compaq 8710p
HP Compaq 8710p

Alike its predecessor, the nw9440, also the HP Compaq 8710p could convince as business notebook. There are a lot of reasons for this, e.g, a good worked-up, robust case in decent business-look.

Also the important input devices are alright. However, typing is judged by individual preferences. A plus is of course the separated numerical pad. Also the hot keys provided above the keyboard are felicitous.

In general the built-in WXGA+ display is alright, but, could not completely convince. Especially its resolution of 1440x900 pixels is a little bit low for a 17 inch display. But, also the moderate illumination is a reason for recommending the WSXGA panel instead.

The absolute highlight of the HP Compaq 8710p is its performance, especially its 3D performance. The NVIDIA Quadro NVS 320M video card surprised us by super performance and benchmark results - Gamers and graphic designer will like it…

The emissions are limited. This is true for noise and temperature emissions, especially in idle mode.

Also the battery runtime is rather good. Although this is not the most important criterion for a DTR, it does not harm. Furthermore, it is possible to equip this notebook with supplement batteries.

 

Many thanks to the company Planet Notebook, who kindly provided us with the reviewed notebook. Here you can configure and also buy this notebook.

Reviewed - HP Compaq 8710p, provided by:
HP Compaq 8710p

Specifications

HP 8710p

:: Processor
:: Mainboard
Intel PM965
:: Memory
2048 MB, DDR2 PC5300 667Mhz SDRAM, 2x 1024MB, max. 2048MB
:: Graphics adapter
NVIDIA Quadro NVS 320M - 256 MB, Core: 575 MHz, Memory: 702 MHz, GDDR3
:: Display
17.0 inch 16:10, 1440x900 pixel, WXGA+ TFT Display, glossy: no
:: Harddisk
160 GB - 5400 rpm, 160 GB 5400 rpm Fujitsu MHW2160BH PL: 160GB, 5400rpm
:: Soundcard
Analog Devices AD1981 HD Audio
:: Connections
1 PC-Card, 6 USB 2.0, 1 Firewire, 1 VGA, 1 HDMI, V.92 Modem, 1 Kensington Lock, 1 Docking Station Port, Audio Connections: Mikrofon, Kopfhörer, Card Reader: 6-in-1,
:: Networking
10/100/1000 LAN Card (10/100/1000MBit), Intel PRO/Wireless 3965ABN (a b n ), 2.0 Bluetooth
:: Optical drive
TSSTcorp DVD-RAM DVD +/-R TS-L632M LightScribe
:: Size
height x width x depth (in mm): 33 x 393 x 275
:: Weight
3.4 kg
:: Battery
73 Wh Lithium-Ion, 73Wh (14.4V) Litium Ionen Akku
:: Price
2150 Euro
:: Operating System
Microsoft Windows XP Professional 32 Bit
:: Additional features
HDD: 160GB, 5400rpm, Fujitsu MHW2160BH PL, Analog Devices AD1981 HD Audio, TSST DVD-RAM TS-L632M LightScribe,

 

[+] compare
HP launches a new business series with new name and slightly differing case.
HP Compag 8710p Image
Excellent feature: Hot keys, which are sensible to touch above the keyboard.
HP Compag 8710p Image
The resolution of the WXGA+ display is for a 17" display a little too low.
HP Compag 8710p Image
The highlight of the HP 8710p is its performance:
HP Compag 8710p Image
Quadro NVS 320M and Core 2 Duo CPU provide top performance for applications and 3D.
HP Compag 8710p Image
The noise emissions are alright, the notebook is quiet in idle mode.
HP Compag 8710p Image
Also the surface temperatures are alright.
HP Compag 8710p Image
The sound of the speakers is also alright, but a little dull.
HP Compag 8710p Image
The battery runtime is excellent and...
HP Compag 8710p Image
The keyboard has a clear layout.
HP Compag 8710p Image
Access rights can be organized and checked by a fingerprint reader.
HP Compag 8710p Image
The HP Compaq 8710p, a 17 inch DTR notebook, is the first representative we reviewed.
HP Compag 8710p Image
Alike its predecessor the 8710p has a decent case in business-look...
HP Compag 8710p Image
...only the area of the keyboard and the area of the hot keys were changed a little bit.
HP Compag 8710p Image
The stability of the case is still very good.
HP Compag 8710p Image
Pressure resistance and flexural rigidity are alright.
HP Compag 8710p Image
It is comprehensively equipped with interfaces, among others 6 USB ports and a HDMI port are provided,...
HP Compag 8710p Image
...unfortunately, they are at the sides of the notebook near the front.
HP Compag 8710p Image
However, a docking port makes it possibly to attach all peripherals via docking station at the back side.
HP Compag 8710p Image
...ranges from 2 to 6 hours.
HP Compag 8710p Image

Pro

  • High-quality materials
  • Robust case, good workmanship
  • Clear layout of the keyboard, high-quality input devices
  • Non-reflecting display
  • Top performance for applications and 3D
  • Fingerprint reader, HDMI Port
  • Acceptable noise emissions and low temperature increase
  • Good battery runtime
  • Contra

  • Partly the case creaks
  • Unreasonable location of ports
  • Moderate illumination of the display, resolution a little bit too low
  • Similar Notebooks

    Price Comparison

    Ciao.uk

    HP Compaq 8710p

    Rating

    HP 8710p
    08/31/2007
    J. Simon Leitner

    Chassis
    86%
    Keyboard
    92%
    Pointing Device
    88%
    Connectivity
    96%
    Weight
    65%
    Battery
    90%
    Display
    78%
    Games Performance
    97%
    Application Performance
    98%
    Temperature
    75%
    Noise
    76%
    Add Points
    94%
    Average
    86%
    89%
    Gaming *
    Weighted Average

    > Notebook / Laptop Reviews and News > Reviews > Archive of our own reviews > Review HP Compaq 8710p Notebook
    Author: J. Simon Leitner, 2007-08-27 (Update: 2013-05- 8)