Notebookcheck Logo

Indiana Jones and the Great Circle nearly got a GTA-style wanted system to stop players from shooting

A screengrab from Indiana Jones and the Great Circle
ⓘ MachineGames
A screengrab from Indiana Jones and the Great Circle
MachineGames considered a Grand Theft Auto-style wanted system to discourage gunplay in Indiana Jones and the Great Circle, design director Jens Andersson revealed. The studio instead relied on shooting penalties and engaging melee combat built around breakable improvised weapons to steer players toward a more character-appropriate approach.

MachineGames built its reputation on the loud, gory gunplay of its Wolfenstein games, which made Indiana Jones and the Great Circle an awkward assignment. Design director Jens Andersson has now explained how the studio kept its first-person adventure from turning into a shooter, and how it considered a Grand Theft Auto-style wanted system along the way.

Speaking on the FRVR Podcast, Andersson said the team's main worry was a habit it expected players to fall into: taking down one guard, picking up the gun he dropped, and clearing the rest of the area with firearms alone. The game, first released on Xbox Series X/S and PC on December 9, 2024, steers players toward stealth and improvised melee weapons instead.

A studio of shooter specialists takes on a family-friendly hero

Andersson told FRVR that the change of direction was very tough for a team that came off Wolfenstein primed for heavy weapons, gore, and running and gunning, only to be asked to make a family-friendly adventure. He described the melee-first combat as one of the features the studio was most afraid of.

The position itself was not new. In August 2024, months before launch, Andersson told PC Gamer that an Indiana Jones game "could never be a shooter, should never be a shooter," because Indy is not a character who shoots his way out of trouble.

What made the job harder was a second requirement: the guns still had to feel good. Andersson said that point was non-negotiable. MachineGames employs many firearms enthusiasts, some of whom compete in shooting, and the many fans of Quake and other shooters would not have accepted poor gunplay. The studio therefore needed both mechanical and narrative ways to dissuade skilled players from gunning everyone down, without making the weapons feel bad to use. Guns remained lethal as a result, with Andersson noting that a headshot still more or less had to be fatal.

The GTA-style star system that stayed on the drawing board

Andersson said the team worked through many designs to get around the problem. One of them was a GTA-style star level system, in which shooting someone would bring in reinforcements. FRVR's account presents it as one of several ideas the studio considered, with no indication that it was ever prototyped, and no such system shipped in the finished game.

Breakable fly swatters and violins did the job instead

"We penalized shooting so much in that game," Andersson said, acknowledging that plenty of players are frustrated by it while maintaining that many more love it. In his telling, what really fixed the problem was not the penalty but the melee combat, which was interesting, fun, and easy to get into.

The breakable weapons system was central to that. Andersson said it went in very late in development and was a little controversial, but once the team saw how effective it was, it began adding stranger items. FRVR lists cast-iron pans, wrenches, mandolins, a broom, a fly swatter, and a violin among the makeshift weapons, all of which break with use. That turnover gives players a reason to try whatever is lying nearby, and Andersson said people end up choosing melee over guns even when guns would be more effective. He characterized the result as slightly slapstick in flavor without being outright slapstick.

FRVR's writer adds that reloading is slow enough that grabbing a nearby object is quicker. That is the outlet's own observation, and Andersson is not quoted on reload speed.

Heading back to Wolfenstein

The studio is now returning to the genre it knows best. On November 12, 2026, Xbox confirmed that Wolfenstein 3 is officially in production at MachineGames, with Brian Bloom and Debra Wilson reprising their roles as BJ Blazkowicz and Grace Walker. No release date, platforms, or gameplay footage have been shared, and Bethesda says the studio will reveal more when it is ready. It will be the first mainline entry in the series since 2017's Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus.

Buy Indiana Jones and the Great Circle on Amazon here

Source(s)

Google LogoAdd as a preferred source on Google
Mail Logo
static version load dynamic
Loading Comments
> Expert reviews and news on laptops, smartphones and tech innovations > News > News Archive > Newsarchive 2026 11 > Indiana Jones and the Great Circle nearly got a GTA-style wanted system to stop players from shooting
Rahim Amir Noorali, 2026-11-16 (Update: 2026-11-16)