Review Apple MacBook 13 inch white

Apple now implements Intel processors in the successors of the iBooks and therby accomplished the transfer to PC technology. Whether this transfer was successful and how the technology, which is new for Macs, harmonizes with the white Macbook can be learned in our detailed review.

Case

The entrance model got a compact completely white case, is well finished and hardly tortions with pressure. However the exterior sides of the case arre quite scratch sensitive - on our test sample already there were some scratches. The top model of the MacBook series is manufactured in tarnished black and possibly somewhat less scratch-sensitive.

The design of the laptop pleases at first view. Particularly the intelligent arrangement of the fan exit on the back of the notebook, the absence of any openings on the bottom and the loudspeakers reflecting on the display are positive features. The integrated iSight camera for video conferences functions perfectly, but rushes strongly with insufficient brightness.

A negative aspect is, that one of the feet is implemented in the battery. With disconnected battery the MacBook stands not stable. Nonetheless the feet are stronger and therefore more stable than with the iBook.

Interfaces

All connection options of the iBook successor are on the left side (ergonomic for righthanded people). As like the large brother, the MacBook Pro 15", the MacBook offers only two USB 2.0 connections. The monitor exit is implemented as Mini-DVI-D (for saving space) and only can be converted to a DVI-D or analogue monitor-exit/TV-out of normal size by an adapter, which costs approximately 20 Euro. This adapter is not included! Further connectionoptions are digital sound entrances and exits, a FireWire 400 port and a Gigabit LAN connection. Other manufacturers usually offer more USB and a Cardreader.

The lack of an infrared port is to be criticized. The existing one is unidiretional and only appropriate for the remote maintenance). Bluetooth 2.0 is included with the small sub-notebook.

interfaces on the left side
optical drive at the right side

Input Devices

The keyboard of the MacBook offers pleasantly large keys and a normal key distance. Both is not common in this class of laptop size. The keys lie somewhat wobbly in the chassis and sometimes jingle with the pressure. The pressure point is well noticeable and the layout is elaborated well for Macusers. Generally it is very pleasant to write with the keyboard, though it can't achieve the quality of MacBook Pro completely.

The broad scrolling trackpad (that's how Apple calls a touchpad) can be handled pleasantly and reacts precisely to inputs. The special functions (scrolling and right-click with 2 fingers) work well as usually and the widescreen format of the touchpad supplies a welcome increase of navigation area.

Tip: In order to be able to accomplish a right mouse-click fast, it is possible to keep 2 fingers on the touchpad and press the mouse key.
However first this must be adjusted in the system attitudes in the menu "keyboard & mouse" - "trackpad" - ". Set two fingers on the trackpad and press the trackpad key to make a secondary click.


Further an infrared remote maintenance "Apple Remote" is added to the MacBook, with which FrontRow can be attended. It functioned perfectly and is expecially useful with presentations.

 

keyboard
touchpad

Display

The reflecting 13" widescreen display offers a working environment with a pleasant fine resolution of 1280x800 pixel. The display brightness, which is on the average 187 cd/m², also allows the usage of the laptop outside in the nature (although in this case reflections of the display disturb noticeable). According to Apple a pole filter is used on the display to avoid reflections. Measured illuminating of 86% is average and the lateral insight range is good, but vertically the display panel loses very fast its colors (see photos below).

182.3
cd/m²
193.5
cd/m²
174.8
cd/m²
174.4
cd/m²
202.1
cd/m²
179.2
cd/m²
183.1
cd/m²
192.4
cd/m²
200
cd/m²
Distribution of brightness
Information
Maximum: 202.1 cd/m²
Average: 186.9 cd/m²
Brightness Distribution: 86 %
colour diagram of the 14" display

The diagram of the color representation shows a lowered blue curve, which means a warm color representation of the screen. 3 overlaying lines bent in 45° would be ideal (from 0,0,0 to 255.255.255).

stability of viewing angles
 

Performance

The performance of the MacBook results - as expected - in good office performance with Windows in classical benchmarks. For current games the integrated graphic is not really suitable, nonetheless aged classics like Quake 3 Arena work sufficiently. Generally the MacBook performed with Windows like a notebook designed for Windows. No lack of speed could be determined. However there are still some missing drivers.

With MacOs X the performance can't be blamed owing to the dual core of processor. You notice immediately that the MacBook was optimized for MacOS X. Everything works smoothly and fast. Older MacOS programs, which are not yet available in universal Binary (compiled also for Intel), are "translated" automatically by Rosetta, which causes a certain lack of speed, but functions without problems.

CINEBENCH 9.5 (MacBook Pro 15" Werte in Klammer)
Rendering (Single   CPU): 281 CB-CPU  (305)
Rendering (Multiple CPU): 535 CB-CPU  (562)
Shading (CINEMA 4D): 321 CB-GFX  (347)
Shading (OpenGL Software Lighting): 1156 CB-GFX  (779)
Shading (OpenGL Hardware Lighting): 1195 CB-GFX (1376)

 

Xbench 1.2 (MacBook Pro 15" values in brackets)
Surprisingly the small MacBook beat the MacBook Pro clearly, although the individual values of the Macbook Pro are usually better (except OpenGL). In OpenGL the ATI Radeon X1600, which is inserted in the MacBook Pro, should beat the integrated Intel graphics clearly. Perhaps there took place a driver update / an operating system update.




Results    103.88    (60.71)
CPU test    68.11    (70.30)
Memory test    115.17    (102.48)
Quartz graphics test    52.79    (52.08)
OpenGL graphics test    197.19    (133.57)
User interface test    15.66    (28.62)
Disk test    30.49    (40.71)

benchmark comparison 3DMark03
benchmark comparison
benchmark comparison PCMark05
3D Mark
3DMark 2001SE5904 points
3DMark 031470 points
3DMark 05542 points
3DMark 06
 
142 points
Help
3DMark 06 in comparison
Sony Vaio VGN-FS485B (min)
 740, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 900
54
   ...
Samsung N145-JP02DE
 N450, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 3150
142
Sony Vaio VPCM11M1E/W
 N450, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 3150
142
Apple MacBook
 T2400, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 950
142
Samsung NP-N150 Eom
 N450, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 3150
143
Asus Eee PC R051PX
 N570, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 3150
144
   ...
Clevo Clevo P157SM (max)
 4930MX, GeForce GTX 880M
29955
PC Mark
PCMark 044543 points
PCMark 052726 points
Help
PCMark 05 in comparison
Acer Aspire One 751 (min)
 Z520, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 500
692
   ...
Sony Vaio VPC-Y21S1E
 U5400, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) HD Graphics
2641
Lenovo X60s
 L2400, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 950
2707
Apple MacBook
 T2400, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 950
2726
Fujitsu-Siemens Pa2510
 TL-50, Radeon Xpress X1200
2731
Dell Latitude D430
 U7600, Graphics Media Accelerator (GMA) 950
2738
   ...
Fujitsu Celsius H710 WXP11DE (max)
 2820QM, Quadro 1000M
13842
120 GB - 5400 rpm
Transfer Rate Minimum: 19.7 MB/s
Transfer Rate Maximum: 39 MB/s
Transfer Rate Average: 31.2 MB/s
Access Time: 16.9 ms
Burst Rate: 90.5 MB/s
CPU Usage: 3.7 %

Emissions

volume development

Without load (internet, text writing) the MacBook remains pleasantly quiet with 30.9 dB. No fan is active and few cm distant in front of the subnotebook quiet noises of the components can be noticed. Only with absolute full load the fan starts to work audible with max 43 dB however not disturbing.

The loudspeakers miss any basses owing to their small design. They do not play loud, but clearly and distortion-free. The concept to install them in the rear and let the display reflect the sounds, functions perfectly. Thus it works as if the sound comes from the display.

The top side of the MacBook remains quite cool in important areas with max. 30°C. Nonetheless it heats up at the bottom to very hot 48°C .

top   bottom
40 °C 40 °C 30 °C   30 °C 32 °C 48 °C
34 °C 30 °C 29 °C   32 °C 37 °C 40 °C
30 °C 29 °C 30 °C   30 °C 31 °C 30 °C
heat distribution

Battery Runtime

Without load the MacBook had energy for about 4h and 45 min - a good value. During the DVD playback (with max. brightness!) it topped in the test even the 2h 45min indicated by Apple by 10 minutes, praiseworthy! Finally a manufacturer, that does not palliates its data!

Current Consumption

Off: 0,4 Watts
Standby: 0,8 Watts
Idle (display off): 12,1 Watts
Idle (min. brightness): 12,6 Watts (obviously switching off the background illumination is hardly useful)
Idle (max. brightness): 16,6 Watts
DVD (max. brightness): 25,4 Watts
WLAN needs about 3 Watts
Bluetooth needs about 0-2 Watts

Windows with Bootcamp

MacOS X pleases - if you don't want to use any software, which does not exist with MacOS, there is no reason to Windows to transfer. Of course it requires a certain time of habituation for newbees. But since the Apple transferred to Intel processors, there is the possibility of an installation of Windows on the notebooks. For the installation a program called Bootcamp is needed. By means of this tool comfortably a driver CD and a suitable partition for Windows XP are created. In the test this functioned simply and without complications. Unfortunately yet the driver support is not complete and the important components keyboard and the trackpad are supported only rudimentarily (WLAN-, Bluetooth and display brightness short keys, scrolling-function of the touchpad are not available yet). Also for the camera and the keyboard lighting drivers do not exist up to now, whereby both do not function in Windows.

Verdict

Apple MacBook 13"

The favorable entrance into the Apple world can convince as a rounded off total concept. The Design is both technical and optical perfectly realized and simply it makes fun to handle the small MacBook. Only the few USB connections and the reflecting display can be criticized. The performance is very good owing to good components and achieves similar values as the IBM/Lenovo T60. Of course games are (owing to the integrated graphics) not really the best for MacBooks.

Users, who want to use Windows exclusively, perhaps should wait for the final version of Bootcamp (is expected with MacOS 10.5.0), since at the moment the input devices are supported insufficiently. With the usage of an external mouse and keyboard hardly any restrictions exist (however this does not make much sense with a Subnotebook).

Tested: Apple MacBook

Specifications

Specifications

Apple MacBook

:: Processor
Intel Core Duo T2400 1.83 GHz (Intel Core Duo)
:: Memory
512 MB, DDR2, PC2 5300, max. 2048MB, 2x256MB (Testgerät hatte 1024MB RAM)
:: Graphics adapter
:: Display
13.3 inch 16:10, 1280x800 pixel, Breitformat Bildschirm mit Hochglanzanzeige, glossy: yes
:: Harddisk
120 GB - 5400 rpm, 120 GB 5400 rpm Seagate Momentus 5400.2 ST96812AS: 120GB, 5400rpm
:: Connections
Ein FireWire 400 Anschluss (8 Watt), zwei USB 2.0 Anschlüsse (bis zu 480 MBit/Sek.), Mini-DVI-Anschluss mit Unterstützung für DVI-, VGA-, S-Video- und Composite-Videoausgabe (erfordert Adapter, die separat erhältlich sind)
:: Size
height x width x depth (in mm): 27.5 x 325 x 227
:: Weight
2.36 kg
:: Battery
, 55 Wattstunden Lithium-Polymer-Batterie mit integrierter LED-Ladeanzeige
:: Price
1193 Euro
:: Additional features
Intel 945GME, HDD: 120GB, 5400rpm, Seagate Momentus 5400.2 ST96812AS, integrierte Intel Soundkarte, Kombiniertes DVD-ROM/CD-RW-Laufwerk mit Einzug,

 

The white MacBook is small, light...
The keyboard can be handled comfortably.
The memory is accessable by screws.
All interfaces are positioned at the left side.
As default MacOS X is installed, which is a serious alternative to Windows.
...beneath the big fan exit, which rarely expels air.
The loudspeakers reflect the sound at the display...
The integrated camera produces sufficient quality for video conferences
The battery runtime is very good for a subnotebook.
Regrettably the surface is very scratch sensitive (the white case).
...and good processed.
The MacBook also is available in black (top version!).

Pro

  • design
  • very silent
  • weight
  • good input devices
  • optimized for MacOS X
  • Contra

  • scratch sensitive
  • moderate windows support (yet)
  • low stability of viewing angles
  • reflecting display
  • foot on battery
  • Similar Laptops

    Rating

    Apple MacBook
    08/31/2007
    Klaus Hinum

    Chassis
    90%
    Keyboard
    94%
    Pointing Device
    90%
    Connectivity
    84%
    Weight
    82%
    Battery
    87%
    Display
    78%
    Games Performance
    57%
    Application Performance
    86%
    Temperature
    74%
    Noise
    90%
    Add Points
    90%
    Average
    84%
    85%
    Subnotebook *
    Weighted Average

    > Notebook / Laptop Reviews and News > Reviews > Archive of our own reviews > Review Apple MacBook 13 inch
    Author: Klaus Hinum, 2006-08- 3 (Update: 2013-05- 8)