Seiko watch from Amazon arrives as a polythene roll, buyer wins double in consumer court

An Amazon customer in India who received a roll of black polythene instead of a Seiko watch has won a full refund with interest, plus compensation. A consumer commission in Visakhapatnam held Amazon and the third-party seller jointly liable, according to The Times of India.
The buyer ordered a Seiko SRPD61K1 (curr. $390 on Amazon US), a green-dial model on a steel bracelet, for her son on 5 May 2025. It was listed at Rs 30,000 (about $320), and she paid Rs 27,000 (about $289) after a 10% discount.
The package arrived a day early, on 11 May. When she opened it, the box held a black polythene roll and no watch. She asked Amazon’s customer care for a return, and the package was collected on 13 May, but the refund never came. She later bought the same watch from a Titan showroom in Visakhapatnam (IN) on 23 June 2025.
Before the commission, the Amazon seller (Samay Watches), said it had packed a genuine watch and handed it over intact to Amazon’s logistics partner. It argued that the switch happened inside Amazon’s delivery network. Amazon said its own investigation found that the correct product had been delivered and a different item returned, which made the buyer completely ineligible for a refund.
The commission was not convinced by either side. It found that both blamed each other but failed to produce documents showing how the refund complaint was handled, further observing that "the complainant has to suffer for no fault."
In its order of 31 October 2026, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission-I directed Amazon and the seller to refund the Rs 27,000 with 6% annual interest from 5 May 2025. They must also pay Rs 21,000 in compensation and Rs 10,000 towards litigation costs, bringing the total to Rs 58,000 (about $620) before interest. A separate cash-on-delivery order was left out of the ruling; the buyer is free to file a fresh complaint over it.






