What’s a sequel we never got, but you wish we did? – Reddit discussion heats up

Under the title "What’s a sequel we never got, but you wish we did?", Reddit users are sharing the games they still dream of seeing continued. The thread, started by user nervuswalker, opens with a classic: the long-awaited sequel to Titanfall 2. An easy choice, as he puts it, since the game tops many wish lists. He also points to Immortals of Aveum as a personal hidden gem – a magical first-person shooter he believes was unfairly overlooked. With the studio now shut down, any hope for a sequel appears to be gone.

The discussion is steeped in nostalgia but also tinged with frustration and a sense of resignation. Many users mourn the end of beloved game series or the closure of iconic studios. A recurring joke throughout the thread is that "Valve can’t count to 3," with references to Half-Life, Portal and Left 4 Dead. Some even argue that the absence of a sequel could be a blessing – preserving the legacy of the originals without the risk of disappointment.

These titles come up particularly often:

• Titanfall 3 - canceled in favor of Apex Legends
• Half-Life 3 - a symbol of eternal gamer hope
• Bully 2 - Rockstar’s unloved orphan
• Sleeping Dogs 2, KOTOR 3, Deus Ex: Mankind Divided (sequel), Days Gone 2, Brütal Legend 2 and more

The thread also delves into the reasons why sequels often never see the light of day: financial risks, studio closures, legal hurdles or shifts in publisher strategy. A standout example is Titanfall 3. Respawn Entertainment had initially begun work on the sequel, but after being acquired by EA, the focus shifted to the battle royale hit Apex Legends. In 2025, EA officially confirmed the cancellation of another Titanfall project, codenamed “R7” – a heavy blow for fans. As one user put it: “I’ll never forgive Apex for robbing us of Titanfall 3.”

Are there any sequels you’ve been hoping for or other reasons you think they never happened? Share your thoughts in the comments!