Deutsch
Español
Français
Italiano
Nederlands
Polski
Português
Русский
Türkçe
Svenska
Chinese
MagyarSamsung Galaxy S5 Mini Smartphone Review
For the original German review, see here.
Mini versions of top smartphones are a good tradition by now and they are not always worse than their bigger siblings. We actually liked the HTC One Mini 2 better than the HTC One M8 in some areas. The current top smartphones are also too big for many buyers with display sizes over 5 inches. Such a 4.5-inch "dwarf" like the Samsung Galaxy S5 Mini might be the solution.
Some features of the bigger sibling are available in the smaller version as well: Fingerprint reader, water- and dust-resistant case, heart rate monitor and the Ultra Power Saving mode. However, you have to waive the high-quality camera from the Galaxy S5: The 8 MP sensor of the Galaxy S5 Mini is average for a mainstream device. The display resolution is lower as well: 720p for the Galaxy S5 Mini, whereas the Galaxy S5 has a Full HD screen.
Obvious devices for a comparison are the Galaxy S5 as well as the HTC One Mini 2. The LG G2 Mini is not a very convenient example of a mini version of a top smartphone in our opinion; the Sony Xperia Z1 Compact on the other hand was good. It is also interesting to see the differences compared to the Galaxy S4 Mini. Other mainstream smartphones in this price range would be the Motorola Moto X, Google Nexus 5 or the LG Optimus L9 II.
Case
The case shares many similarities with its sibling: The matte back with a subtle dot pattern, the chrome-colored frame with the two surrounding grooves and the silver frame of the home button really remind us of the Samsung Galaxy S5. Samsung fans love the case because it is light; the people that do not like Samsung revile it because it is completely made of plastic. As a fact, the material impression is not as sophisticated as the HTC One Mini 2, for example, which is completely made of metal. However, the case is sturdy: Pressure on the back or the front is not visible on the screen.
The back with its roughened surface has good grip and it is easy to hold the very narrow case in the hand. The design is obviously a matter of taste, it is not as reduced as the HTC One Mini 2 or the iPhone 5s, but it combines several shapes, which does not look as sophisticated as other high-end smartphones in our opinion. On the one hand, the design is not striking enough to attract attention, on the other hand, it will probably scare off fans of simpler shapes.
One highlight is certainly once again the good maintainability: The battery can be removed or replaced if necessary. Just like the bigger sibling, the case has been certified according to IP-67, which means it is water- and dust-resistant. The smartphone can be submerged and resists sweat and rain, but the removable back cover has to be attached correctly, which is also indicated by a popup quite often. Interesting: It seems that Samsung found a way to make the live USB port waterproof. The Samsung Galaxy S5 still used a cover for that, now you can submerge the smartphone without a cover.
Connectivity
The USB 3.0 port from the bigger Galaxy S5 is unfortunately not available in the "Mini" version and you will have to live with the slightly slower USB 2.0 port. The system memory is also 500 MB smaller than the larger sibling at 1.5 GB. Near Field Communication (NFC) is possible with the Galaxy S5 Mini as well, but the USB port does not support MHL anymore.
The internal storage is still 16 GB in the standard version and can be expanded via MicroSD card. The fingerprint reader, which is supposed to protect the smartphone very effectively, is once again integrated into the home button and worked reliably in a first test, but similar to the Galaxy S5, you have to precisely swipe from the top to the bottom to unlock the device. If it does not work with the fingerprint, you can also unlock the device with a password.
At the back is once again a heart rate monitor, which showed different results with multiple measurements and resulted in a pretty high resting heart rate of almost 90.
Software
Samsung's Touch Wiz user interface is based on Android 4.4 and there are just small differences compared to the Galaxy S5: The app "My Magazine", which was the news aggregator for the Galaxy S5, is not available ex-works, but it can be activated in the settings. Otherwise, the interface is very intuitive for Android users and Samsung veterans, but new users might be overwhelmed by the features at first. The Galaxy S5 offered a few more features, but the number is still huge.
Samsung also installs some useful apps, for example "S Health", which is supposed to improve fitness. Those apps are obviously available from other companies, but the direct integration of the heart rate monitor, the immediate start of the step counter and some other features are comfortable and free features of the app. The voice control "S Voice" is still on board, just like the calendar app "S Planner", the picture effect from "Studio" or "Smart Remote" that can be used to control the TV via infrared sensor at the top. Apps can also be copied to the SD card via "Application Manager" as long as the author of the app allows it.
However, there are also some apps that were installed for advertising purposes. This bloatware includes apps from shopping sites, food and hotel services. All in all, there are around five apps, so they can quickly be deleted.
Communication & GPS
The super fast wireless standard 802.11ac that we know from the Galaxy S5 is not supported by the S5 Mini. However, wireless networks up to the standard 802.11n should be sufficient for most users right now.
The wireless networks are fairly flexible: Thanks to four frequencies for GSM and 3G each, as well as six frequencies for LTE, you should be able to establish a connection in most countries around the world. The GSM and 3G signals are good and largely sufficient in the metropolitan area most of the time. We cannot test the LTE signal right now due to the bad network coverage of our provider.
The GPS module also supports the Russian Glonass network and the smartphone offers several settings: You can locate your position with the WLAN and mobile network only to save power or use them to enable a more precise location (A-GPS).
The signal quality outdoors is good: The device quickly found enough satellites to locate our position down to 7 meters (~23 feet). However, the signal is not sufficient to establish a connection indoors; you can only use the location via WLAN and mobile network in this case.
We took the Galaxy S5 Mini and a professional navigation device, the Garmin Edge 500, on a bike ride. The two devices showed similar results, and the track length that was determined by Runtastic did not really differ, either. Both show quite a precise track and the Galaxy S5 Mini is even a bit more accurate around the bridge, but it lost us in the forest for a while in return.
Telephone features and Voice Quality
The phone app did not change compared to the Galaxy S5: Large pictures and rectangular buttons dominate the picture and remind us of the current Windows design language. The app still works in landscape mode, which is a good idea. The buttons are slightly smaller compared to the larger sibling due to the screen size, but still big enough for users with limited eyesight.
The voice quality during calls is similar to the Galaxy S5, but not quite as brilliant as the HTC One Mini 2, which has an excellent voice quality and also a very high maximum volume because the integrated speaker is used as an earpiece. However, the recipient understands us very well with the Galaxy S5 Mini and the recipient also confirms a decent noise filtering in louder environments. The hands-free feature via speaker works pretty well, while the "Additional Volume" button of the phone app once again only resulted in a small improvement.
Cameras & Multimedia
The camera of the Galaxy S5 Mini has been reduced to a mainstream level with 8 Megapixels. Every user has to decide for himself, whether he needs the gigantic 16 Megapixels of the Galaxy S5 or not, but the results of the Galaxy S5 Mini are actually pretty good: The colors are good and the pictures are neither too bright nor too dark. At the same time you can see many details, only very big colored surfaces show some pixels when you have a closer look. The edges are not as sharp compared to the Sony A57 or the Nokia Lumia 1020, but still more than sufficient if you do not want to create a billboard.
Overall, we like the 8 MP camera of the Samsung Galaxy S5 Mini, especially the reliable autofocus, even though it is not the fastest. The sensor also works pretty well in dark environments without the flash. This does affect the sharpness, but color noise is only an issue in very dark environments in return. The LED flash does a good job. Videos can be recorded in Full HD and we like the picture quality as well as the smooth frame rate.
The front camera takes decent pictures with its comparatively low resolution of 2.1 Megapixels, but you should not zoom too much. The mandatory selfies work pretty well and the sensor does a good job in dark environments, but it has to since there is no flash at the front.
Accessories
A headset is included with the Galaxy S5 Mini. It is the standard Samsung model, which also comes with the Galaxy S5. Furthermore, you get a quick start guide, a micro USB cable and the power adaptor. There are not many additional accessories for the Galaxy S5 Mini at a first look, and Samsung only offers cases right now.
However, you can, for instance, connect the Galaxy S5 Mini with the Samsung Galaxy Gear Fit, a smart watch with focus on the fitness features. A more detailed description of the qualities and the battery runtime is available in the review of the Galaxy S5. The smart watch Galaxy Gear can also be connected with the device.
Warranty
The warranty period in Germany is 24 months. Samsung does not offer a warranty extension.
Input Devices & Handling
The touchscreen controls are very precise, even in the peripheral areas and the screen recognizes up to ten fingers simultaneously. Thanks to its high-sensitivity mode, you can also use it on cold days with thin gloves. We could not determine an input delay and the surface provided good gliding capabilities. There is almost no friction for the finger.
Samsung adjusted the keyboard pretty comprehensively, but the input of the Galaxy S5 Mini, probably due to the smaller screen, does not have all the options of the Galaxy S5: The separate number keys have been waived, including the option to assign frequently used words with them. Still, the keyboard can be adjusted with multiple settings and the other input methods are comprehensive as well with alternatives like voice or Swype inputs. However, writing on the panel itself is not possible this time.
Typing works pretty well, even though the keys are now very close to each other in portrait mode. Still, typos were rare and the system automatically corrects wrong inputs if you activate it.
The eye tracking for browsing through pages is not implemented this time, but some apps once again support gestures from a finger that hovers above the display for additional features. The enhanced gesture control is available as well: Swipe across the screen to take a snapshot or hold the smartphone to your ear to call the opened contact automatically, which can be quite useful.
Display
Compared to the Galaxy S5, the display resolution was reduced to 1280x720 pixels, but that is still an improvement over the Galaxy S4 Mini, where the screen only had a resolution of 960x540 pixels. Samsung still uses a Super-AMOLED display that can show rich colors and basically an infinite contrast thanks to the absolute black. In return, there are often some issues with the brightness, so it can be tricky to use it outdoors.
The black value is actually 0 cd/m², so black areas are really shown without any other colors or color shades. The maximum brightness on the other hand is clearly below the LCD displays from the Sony Xperia Z1 Compact or the HTC One Mini 2. 307 cd/m² is the maximum result for the Galaxy S5 Mini, but we were able to measure up to 441 cd/m² with direct light on the light sensor. It seems that Samsung has some brightness reserves for very bright environments.
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||
Brightness Distribution: 88 %
Center on Battery: 288 cd/m²
Contrast: ∞:1 (Black: 0 cd/m²)
ΔE Color 6.18 | 0.5-29.43 Ø5
ΔE Greyscale 5.52 | 0.57-98 Ø5.3
Gamma: 2.23
The complete black theoretically results in an infinite contrast ratio, which results in a very vivid and rich color presentation. Samsung once again uses different display modes, so that every user can adjust the display according to their needs, but the smartphone can also select the corresponding color mode automatically. The “Dynamic” mode has the richest colors, but it looks a bit artificial. “Cinema” is the other extreme with a very reduced saturation and a much less dynamic picture. Somewhere in between are the modes “Standard” and “Professional Picture”.
We use the software CalMAN and special measurement devices to see the impacts of the four color modes on the color presentation and to check the color accuracy of the display. The “Cinema” mode shows the lowest deviation from the ideal value of the color space sRGB in general. The colors are too saturated in the “Dynamic” mode and medium gray tones have a visible blue cast. The latter is also present in the “Cinema” mode, but not as strong.
It is a joy to watch content in the modes “Dynamic” or “Standard” since the colors appear very vivid and rich. However, you should select the “Cinema” mode if you want the most natural picture. The automatic selection tends to favor rich colors instead of a natural presentation based on our experiences.
A device with a glossy display will never be perfect for the use outdoors. Still, you can use the Galaxy S5 Mini on the road: The brightness sensor quickly recognizes the environment and adjusts the display brightness accordingly. We could always see the display content on a sunny day with clouds, but you will have to live reflections.
As we mentioned before, the display brightness can be raised above the maximum value in very bright environments, so the visibility of the display content was still decent. Using the Galaxy S5 Mini indoors or in the shade is no problem.
Samsung's Super-AMOLED displays always left a positive impression in terms of viewing angle stability so far. That does not change with the Galaxy S5 Mini; the display can maintain its full contrast even with very flat viewing angles.
Performance
The Samsung Galaxy S5 Mini is a significant step down compared to the Galaxy S5 in terms of performance: The SoC Exynos 3470 with 1.4 GHz has a much lower clock than the Snapdragon 801 MSM8974AC with 2.45 GHz, which is used for the Galaxy S5. The memory was reduced by 512 MB to 1,536 MB, and the integrated graphics solution, the Mali 400 MP4, is slower than the Adreno 330 in the Galaxy S5.
The SoC inside the Galaxy S5 Mini is actually a bit slower compared to other mainstream smartphones, at least in the synthetic benchmarks. This is not really an issue in practice, but there can be small stutters, for example, when you open the notification center while you use another app. The Multi-Window mode was also smoother on the Galaxy S5.
According to our measurements, the Galaxy S5 Mini cannot keep up with its predecessor, the Galaxy S4 Mini, either. The Sony Xperia Z1 Compact on the other hand almost performs at the level of the big Galaxy S5 and manages high-end results. This also means it is clearly ahead of the Galaxy S5 Mini.
| Geekbench 2 - 32 Bit - Total Score (sort by value) | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 mini | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 | |
| Samsung Galaxy S4 Mini GT-I9195 | |
| Sony Xperia Z1 Compact | |
| LG G2 Mini | |
| Google Nexus 5 | |
| Quadrant Standard Edition 2.0 - --- (sort by value) | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 mini | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 | |
| Motorola Moto X 1. Gen 2013 | |
| Google Nexus 5 | |
| LG D605 Optimus L9 II | |
The GPU is the Mali 400 MP4 and its four cores are clocked at a fast 700 MHz. Still, the graphics performance of the Galaxy S5 Mini is not on the level of other mainstream smartphones. The Samsung Galaxy S5 and the Xperia Z1 Compact are in a completely different league anyway.
| 3DMark | |
| 1280x720 offscreen Ice Storm Unlimited Score (sort by value) | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 mini | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 | |
| Sony Xperia Z1 Compact | |
| LG G2 Mini | |
| Google Nexus 5 | |
| 1280x720 offscreen Ice Storm Unlimited Graphics Score (sort by value) | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 mini | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 | |
| Sony Xperia Z1 Compact | |
| LG G2 Mini | |
| Google Nexus 5 | |
| 1280x720 offscreen Ice Storm Unlimited Physics (sort by value) | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 mini | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 | |
| Sony Xperia Z1 Compact | |
| LG G2 Mini | |
| Google Nexus 5 | |
| Basemark X 1.1 | |
| Medium Quality (sort by value) | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 mini | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 | |
| LG G2 Mini | |
| Google Nexus 5 | |
| High Quality (sort by value) | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 mini | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 | |
| Google Nexus 5 | |
In terms of browsing performance and technologies like HTML5 or JavaScript, the Samsung Galaxy S5 Mini is pretty good and can manage an average spot among our comparison units. It is slightly ahead of the Galaxy S4 Mini, but the Galaxy S5 is much faster.
| Peacekeeper - --- (sort by value) | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 mini | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 | |
| Samsung Galaxy S4 Mini GT-I9195 | |
| Sony Xperia Z1 Compact | |
| LG G2 Mini | |
| Motorola Moto X 1. Gen 2013 | |
| Google Nexus 5 | |
| LG D605 Optimus L9 II | |
| Octane V2 - Total Score (sort by value) | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 mini | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 | |
| Sony Xperia Z1 Compact | |
| LG G2 Mini | |
| Motorola Moto X 1. Gen 2013 | |
| Google Nexus 5 | |
| Google Nexus 5 | |
| Mozilla Kraken 1.1 - Total (sort by value) | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 mini | |
| Samsung Galaxy S5 | |
| Sony Xperia Z1 Compact | |
| LG G2 Mini | |
| Motorola Moto X 1. Gen 2013 | |
| Google Nexus 5 | |
| LG D605 Optimus L9 II | |
* ... smaller is better
The Galaxy S5 Mini can at least beat its predecessor in regard to the storage performance: The 16 GB eMMC flash storage transfers data quicker than the storage of the Galaxy S4 Mini. There are also slight performance advantages compared to other mainstream smartphones. We can determine fairly short loading times for apps on the Galaxy S5 Mini.
Gaming
We tried some of the most GPU-demanding titles from the Google Play Store to check the gaming performance of the Galaxy S5 Mini: Asphalt 8 is a fast racing game with nice environments, Gangstar Vegas reminds us of GTA and you can race fast jet skis with nicely animated water in Riptide GP2. All three games run smoothly on the Mali 400 MP4, but not completely without dropped frames. The best experience is Riptide GP2, we can see some dropped frames in Asphalt 8 and you quickly notice that the frame rate in Gangstar Vegas is around 30 fps because there are stutters and the loading times can be quite long as well.
This means you should try the titles on the Samsung Galaxy S5 Mini and see if they run smoothly if you want to play complex games. We were able to play all tested games, but you will need more performance if you want a completely smooth experience for every title. However, the performance is usually sufficient for most games: Angry Birds: Star Wars 2 and similar titles are much less demanding.
Emissions
Temperature
Samsung did its homework in terms of heat development: There is only a slight warming under maximum load. The absolute maximum is 34.9 °C (94.8 °F) at the front; the back is slightly cooler in general. This means the Galaxy S5 Mini stays cool compared to the Sony Xperia Z1 Compact or the HTC One Mini 2. The perceptible warming is also much lower than the HTC One Mini 2, for instance, because plastic conducts heat worse than metal. The predecessor Galaxy S4 Mini was also noticeably warmer with up to 41 °C (105.8 °F).
The warming during idle is highest in the area of the front earpiece with up to 30.2 °C (86.36 °F), which is a bad spot because the ear is a pretty heat-sensitive spot on the body. However, the warming is reasonably low, so this small issue is negligible.
(+) The maximum temperature on the upper side is 34.9 °C / 95 F, compared to the average of 35 °C / 95 F, ranging from 21.9 to 56 °C for the class Smartphone.
(+) The bottom heats up to a maximum of 32.3 °C / 90 F, compared to the average of 33.8 °C / 93 F
(+) In idle usage, the average temperature for the upper side is 28.7 °C / 84 F, compared to the device average of 32.7 °C / 91 F.
Speakers
Just like the Galaxy S5 or the Galaxy S4 Mini, the speaker sits at the back and has to do the job alone – a second speaker for stereo sound similar to the HTC One Mini 2 is not available. The position at the back has advantages and disadvantages: Put the phone on a solid surface and you can use it as an additional resonance body that enhances the sound. However, if you put it on a smooth surface or hold it in your hand and cover the speaker with a finger, the sound is muffled.
Overall, the quality is actually not bad: The maximum volume is high, but the sound stays defined and clear. High and medium tones appear balanced in general, but the bass is, as usual, not very clear. The HTC One Mini 2 generally produces much better sound and even creates a stereo effect. Compared to the Sony Xperia Z1 Compact, however, we think that the Galaxy S5 Mini is superior in terms of sound quality. This means the Galaxy S5 Mini can take second place amongst our three comparison devices.
Energy Management
Power Consumption
If you compare the power consumption of the Samsung Galaxy S5 Mini with the Sony Xperia Z1 Compact or the HTC One Mini 2, you can quickly see that Samsung has an advantage in this section: It uses the least amount of power in all tested scenarios. Compared to the predecessor, it is evident that the consumption under load in particular was reduced. However, there is one restriction: The Sony Xperia Z1 Compact with its Qualcomm Snapdragon 800 is much more powerful compared to the HTC One Mini 2 or the Galaxy S5 Mini and needs more power as a result.
The low consumption results of the Galaxy S5 Mini are impressive nonetheless: The device just needs 0.4 Watts during idle when the display is active. The maximum consumption is up to 1.1 Watts during idle and up to 2.4 Watts under load, which is roughly 50% of the maximum consumption from the HTC One Mini 2.
| Off / Standby |   0 / 0.1 Watt |
| Idle |  0.4 / 0.9 / 1.1 Watt |
| Load |
1.8 / 2.4 Watt |
    
| |
Battery Runtime
Such low power consumption in combination with the increased battery capacity of 8.1 Watts (Samsung Galaxy S4 Mini: 7.07 Watts) should provide excellent battery runtimes, right? The results are actually impressive: Web browsing via WLAN is possible for 14:09 hours with the Galaxy S5 Mini, the predecessor only managed 2 hours less and the HTC One Mini 2 just lasts for 9:06 hours. The Xperia Z1 Compact on the other hand manages a terrific runtime of 19:04 hours and beats our review unit.
However, you can still browse the web for almost two whole business days, which is impressive. There are also two different power saving modes that we already know from the Galaxy S5: The Ultra Power Saving mode only uses the colors black and white for the display and limits the functionality, but gets a couple of hours standby from an almost empty battery in return.
Verdict
The Samsung Galaxy S5 Mini is a reduced version of the Galaxy S5 in terms of performance and features, but there are still several features that let the borders between mainstream and high-end blur: Fingerprint reader, water- and dust-resistant case, great and comprehensive software, convenient handling, good camera, high-quality display, low temperature development as well as the good speaker are advantages of the smartphone. Last but not least, you also get great battery runtimes.
However, the competitors Sony Xperia Z1 Compact and the HTC One Mini 2 are also very good. If you want more performance, you should get the Sony smartphone, which supports 802.11ac WLAN as well. The One Mini 2 has a metal case and the best speakers in this product class. The biggest advantage of the Samsung Galaxy S5 Mini is that it has no real drawbacks in any category, even though the two closest rivals might have the advantage in some details.
Small issues would be the fingerprint reader, which is sometimes tricky to operate, the preloaded bloatware and the screen, which could have a higher resolution. The polycarbonate case is probably going to cause a debate for every Galaxy device, and the design is not as appealing to the masses compared to many other smartphones. We can still give a purchase recommendation since there is currently no smartphone in this product class that ticks so many correct boxes.
We add another point to the overall rating because we are convinced by the comprehensive software with dozens of options to personalize the phone, the comprehensive explanations of the features and the acceptably short loading times.
